Marketing Operators
Marketing Operators

Why Is Community an Undervalued Growth Lever? (MacCoy Merkley, PLG)

16h ago1:04:1813,741 words

The Podafi briefing · AI analysis

DTC brands weigh community ownership against authentic peer-to-peer trust

5 min brief · 4 takeaways · Based on this episode’s transcript

The 30-second brief

TL;DR
  • 01Fan-created Facebook groups require an ownership decision between brand control and authentic peer-to-peer trust.
  • 02Community building resembles SEO, requiring consistent daily management to compound over years.
  • 03Explicitly soliciting specific user-generated content yields authentic creative assets for paid advertising.

The big picture

DTC operators struggle to justify community investments because direct revenue attribution is difficult. Brands choose between owning spaces for direct marketing or letting fans moderate to preserve authentic peer-to-peer trust, treating community as a slow-burn retention channel rather than an immediate revenue driver.

Useful for: DTC marketing operators deciding how to build, leverage, or measure brand communities for customer retention.

Synthesis of podcast conversations. Speaker claims are not independently verified.

01Community strategy

Fan-created groups require an ownership decision

Hexclad let a fan named Bobby maintain ownership of their Facebook group to preserve an authentic feel. Portland Leather Goods eventually built and owned their own 250,000-member group to control the space.

Why it matters. Owning the group allows direct promotion in owned media and controlled moderation, while leaving it fan-run may protect the peer-to-peer trust that makes the community valuable.

Your next move · Podafi’s suggestion

Audit existing social channels for organic customer conversations. If a fan group exists, build a relationship with the admin before deciding whether to launch a competing brand-owned group.

The catch. Taking over a fan-run group can alienate the original creator and shift the community tone from authentic peer advice to branded marketing.

Transcript evidence

Evidence summary · paraphrased

Hexclad's group was started by a fan. The team decided not to take control because they felt customer-to-customer interaction would disappear if the brand moderated it.

02Community strategy

Treat community building like slow-burn SEO

The host compares community building to SEO. It requires putting a person in a seat to manage it daily, but the compounding growth takes years to materialize into a significant business asset.

Why it matters. Brands focused purely on immediate acquisition might neglect community, missing out on long-term compounding retention benefits that eventually drive significant lifetime value.

Your next move · Podafi’s suggestion

Assign community management to an existing organic social team member rather than hiring a full-time manager until the group reaches a scale requiring dedicated attention.

The catch. Do not expect immediate revenue spikes. If your brand relies heavily on new customer acquisition, community might not be the highest leverage activity right now.

Transcript evidence

Evidence summary · paraphrased

The host notes that community growth is a slow burn similar to SEO, requiring consistent effort over years to compound into a meaningful business asset.

03Creative strategy

Explicitly solicit specific user-generated content

A reading glasses brand incentivized older customers with a discount code to leave video reviews. The raw content did not work on its own, but editors cut it into compelling paid ads.

Why it matters. Passive monitoring rarely yields usable creative. Explicitly asking for specific moments generates high-quality, authentic assets that perform well in paid advertising and reinforce the buyer journey.

Your next move · Podafi’s suggestion

Identify a specific, high-emotion moment in your customer journey. Email recent buyers asking them to submit photos or short videos of that exact moment in exchange for a small incentive.

The catch. Customer-generated content might not perform well as organic social posts. You will likely need a skilled editor to cut the raw footage into compelling paid ad formats.

Transcript evidence

From the transcript

“I don't think any of it really worked on its own because these are like not content creators. But when you activate that much content from your customers at volume, you can usually put some really compelling ads together”
Read the source transcript ↗

Evidence summary · paraphrased

A reading glasses brand incentivized older customers with a discount code to leave video reviews. The speaker noted the raw content did not work on its own, but edited into compelling ads.

04Acquisition economics

Align referral discounts with blended acquisition cost

Ridge structures its referral program to offer prospects a discount marginally stronger than their blended customer acquisition cost. Referrers receive gifts with purchase, graduating to a social affiliate program after five referrals.

Why it matters. Tying referral incentives directly to blended customer acquisition cost ensures the program remains marginally more efficient than paid media channels while rewarding loyal advocates.

Your next move · Podafi’s suggestion

Calculate your current blended customer acquisition cost. Set your referral discount for new buyers just below that number, and offer a physical gift with purchase to the referring customer.

The catch. Blended customer acquisition cost fluctuates with paid media efficiency. Review and adjust your referral discount thresholds regularly to ensure the program remains profitable.

Transcript evidence

From the transcript

“as long as the discount that we're giving to the prospect is marginally stronger than like our blended cac or I'll take that all day long”
Read the source transcript ↗

Evidence summary · paraphrased

Ridge offers a referral discount marginally stronger than their blended customer acquisition cost, noting they will give a hundred dollars off if their blended cost is a hundred twenty dollars.

From listening to doing

Take one idea into the week

Suggested experiments, not proven results. Choose what fits your brand.

Test community promotion in post-purchase flows

  1. 01Create a variant of your current post-purchase email that includes a dedicated block inviting the customer to join your Facebook group.
  2. 02Send the variant to a randomized segment of recent purchasers while keeping the control group on the original email.
  3. 03Track the click-through rate to the group and the subsequent join rate over the following weeks.

Measure: Compare the Facebook group join rate between the variant and control segments to measure the incremental lift in community acquisition.

Guardrail: Monitor overall post-purchase email click-through rates and conversion rates to ensure the community call-to-action does not distract from primary post-purchase goals like repeat purchases or review requests.

Context & limitations
  • Direct revenue attribution for community members is difficult and often relies on self-reported surveys or skewed lifetime value averages heavily influenced by whale customers.
  • Community management requires consistent moderation to prevent spam and maintain brand safety, which can strain small marketing teams expecting immediate daily financial returns.
  • The value of a community is highly dependent on the brand's existing customer demographics and their natural platform preferences, meaning tactics from one brand may not replicate elsewhere.

Listen to the conversation

0:000:00
Original episode description

“Don’t not do good marketing just because you can’t measure it that well.” How do customer communities pay off for both acquisition and LTV? MacCoy Merkley (CMO, Portland Leather Goods) joins Connor Rolain (Head of Growth, HexClad) and Connor MacDonald (CMO, Ridge) to unpack how one fan’s group became a 250K-member community. Ridge, built on new customers, weighs whether to follow. PLG runs its ow...

Transcript

EN

All right, we are back.

Welcome to episode 138 of the Marketing Operator's podcast.

We have Conor McDonnell that we got McCoy. McCoy, I'm blanking on your-- McCoy, Merkley. Yeah. Yeah, but--

McCoy, Merkley, sorry. I had a brain fart, you know, it's 9 a.m. here. But yeah, we're excited.

“I think this is the first time all three of us have done a pod.”

Maybe, maybe not. Maybe we didn't want to wild back. But nonetheless, we're excited for today. We're going to go deep on community today. I'm really excited, because I think community

is just such an undervalued growth lever from, I think, an acquisition standpoint and just the lifetime value perspective. So I'm excited to go deep on that. We had a really fun conversation on community

leg growth with Ari Ferrwarda from half days, you know, almost a year or so ago. And it's really cool to, like, see all the fun, engaging ways that they're activated in their community. And I know y'all are doing some really interesting stuff on your community front as well.

So maybe to start things off just like, when you hear community, and when you think of community at Portland leather, like, what does that mean to you? How does that actually, like, tactically come to life? I've heard that y'all have one of the most robust Facebook groups

of any D to C brand out there. So could you just give us the run through of all that? And what it looks like at Portland Other? Yeah, yeah.

So, okay, first thing I want to do is big marketers who, like,

tune into the show to, like, learn about meta-haxence, or whatever it is to not skip this episode. Don't skip it, please sit around. I know community is like, this word, it's sort of mushy. And like, we don't really know, like, what it means

or how did I dissect it? If you're the tactical marketer, if you're the capital M marketer, right, like, you care about culture and community, like, this is already native to you. But if you're somebody who mostly focuses on, like, advertising

and metrics and all of these things, like, this may not be the most interesting topic for you. But I beg you, please, not to skip it, because it is so important. It's been absolutely transformative for our brand. It's really where we flip the switch from being acquisition

led brand to a brand who pulls in 60% or more of their revenue from returning customers. And that community is such an important part of that. So, that's, like, opening into a police, for the love of God, don't skip this.

Level up, try to learn, like, more about this thing. And see if there's anything you can do in your brand. Maybe not, who knows? But you run a brand. Maybe if you're a drop-shipper, this might not be for you,

but if you run a brand, there's so many things you can do with community that are going to benefit you. So, in AKS, there's my tip. Important other goods has, what can only be described as, like, an insane community?

I had to be, like, scolded away from calling it, like, a cult following several times.

“But that's, that's honestly probably the best word for it.”

And it's something that we've nurtured up over multiple years. It really started coming to a head in 2022. We made a number of changes to our business that we can kind of dissect. But the main being that we started our own Facebook group,

a little bit into 2022. And that community has now grown to be over 250,000 members. That community posts thousands upon thousands of posts per week. There is multi-six figures of, like,

like, some, and reactions happening in that group. And just tens and tens of thousands of comments, every single week. Those aren't monthly sets, those are per week. So, this is like the hub where all our customers

are coming together and talking about our products. I know you have one similar, so I'm excited to kind of like chop up the difference between those two. But that's kind of like, that's the epicenter of where our community happens.

And like, we're trying to funnel customers who have an extra love for the brand or advocacy for the brand. We're trying to get them funneled into that vessel for their enthusiasm, that community group

and that's our Facebook group. Which happens to pair well, again, been appealed to the advertisers with where we spend most of our money, which is on things like meta, aka Facebook.

So, they're already on Facebook, seeing your ads. It's not that big of a deal to get them over to a Facebook group, in most cases.

So, let's talk about like, first off the inception

of this group, like when did this group come to be? And like, initially, why did you make this group? And then, how does this group mature? Like, what tactics are y'all employing to create awareness and overall just like growth

of members in this group? Okay, this is where I think, and I am excited to hear you, the Genesis story of, you know, cook with hexclad and where it started.

“Because the truth is, we didn't start it at all, really.”

Like, at all. The first thing, really, okay, excited we did. We didn't start ours either. Okay, I can't wait to hear the story here. Maybe it's similar.

So, we first thing we noticed, and maybe you have this already in your brand new, you're not quite aware of it. But the first thing we noticed is people are spending a lot of time commenting on ads, right? So, like, somebody buys the product,

then they see the ad again, whether it's true, like your marketing campaign or whatever, just normal action. And they were started to comment on the post, "Hey, I love my product." Okay, that's great.

One or two comments is nothing. And then it started to really stack up, and it started to stack up specifically on one main ad that we were spending a lot against, in, you know, 2018, 2019, things like this.

And we just were sitting around, scratching our heads going, like, my God, there's so many comments on here.

What do we do with this?

And first and foremost, it turned into this, like,

“forum board, where it wasn't like an official community,”

like space, but people were commenting and saying, I love this, people were asking questions to other customers and getting help. Like, what color do you think I should get? What size do you think I should get?

Another customers were helping them out. And then at some point, I work with our social media manager to start kind of like moderating, slash, like, helping and assisting the customers

who weren't getting maybe responsible for their customers. But first and foremost, we're like, let's let the customers interact. If they can help each other,

we think that that's the best possible case scenario. You take your best friend shopping, and they're like, you know, I like that on you, or, you know, that's a great bag. Let's rate dress, whatever it is.

That recommendation means so much more coming from, like, a customer or friendly voice,

that that's we wanted to have that first and foremost.

But we need to moderate this one specific ad. And that slowly spilled over into those customers, finding a natural home for themselves, inside of another brand's Facebook group. So somebody had done the hard work that we were avoiding

and like actually created a container for that conversation. And they had a self-titled Facebook group, which was originally made by a fan. So it wasn't like a brand created one. And they eventually modified the title

of that customer Facebook group to be blank, brand, and Portland, leather goods. And this brand was like like a super native fit for us. It was like completely different category, different material.

We were kind of shocked by this. Wait, so that is, so that is like, that is combined these two brands together. And like, this is where we're gonna talk about both, where they all, like, at least somewhat close together

and like what the product was. Every brand I talk to has the same problem right now. He need way more ads and you need better ads. We have agencies, creators, and AI that all help with volume, but then there can be a week of back and forth.

There's a lot of logistics and a lot of people in the way before any of it is even ready to launch. At Winks, we skip all of that. We have runeth that's helping with everything. Runeth makes almost all of our statics directly in Slack.

They come out launched pretty much one-shotted uploads, analyzes them, does all of it. Runeth also helps with our tribe. We're getting so many videos, but we wanna make sure that they are appropriate

and hitting the right things. Runeth has been trained on all of the feedback and comments that I've given to tribe creators. So it is briefing them, it is cueing all of them, and it's messaging them feedback based on what's working

in our ad account. Runeth has started building all of our landing pages for us. A lot of people are talking about having ad and landing page compliance together. Runeth has made that possible by in loudness

to ship really good landing pages very quickly. Runeth has a homework, it has all of the context of Winks and our performance. If you wanna check it out, go to runeth.com and start your 14-day trial.

Tell them Cody sent you so I can hook you up. Not even close. Like we're talking, I wanna name the brand, but it's like a shoe brand, like a shoe and sandals brand and not like leather sandals, like not close at all.

And I'm literally must have just been that the moderator or the person on the group happened to like both brands. And took her obsession was like, I don't know, I wish you knew the original number was,

“I go back and think them 'cause I think I owe them”

a thank you at least or a big check. But in any case, she modified the name of the group, to be blank and important leather goods.

And less than a year later, we had basically kicked the us

but like the group owner had kicked the other brand off the headline title, and it became a Portland leather goods group. So we inherited and cross pollinated something like 32,000 original members from the original brands group over to this brand group.

So I'll pause there 'cause that's actually not the group running today that has 250,000 members, but that is the origin story of like how we got there. I'm my curiosity's ablaze. I needed to know how you started your group.

It was anything like that. Well, can I just quickly say, can I just quickly say, I think in a hair it is a very generous term, McCoy. It sounds more like an insurgency that would come to mind for real-offs.

Yeah, yeah, parasitic behavior. You guys like sort of consume the host organism. That's a comes to mind. You know, Portland a good community, it does sound crazy. You guys are like they're hosting mutinies

amongst other Facebook groups. I think this is, this is I couldn't have asked for better fields you'd love. Okay, you're dropping the veil. Yeah, it's where parasitic, I don't know.

I don't know, maybe that's too strong word for me, but we definitely would insurgency, I like, well let's get parasitic for now. I'm a brand new little bit. I'm gonna skip parasitic, I could all accept insurgent.

Well, so who owns the group today? Like, do you guys own that group or do someone else own the group?

“So that original group is still, I believe it's owned”

by the original founder of it. The 250,000 member group, you see today, if you go to Facebook and you type in insiders, we own that group, but this is an offshoot or the original group.

And I don't know the member count off the top of my head, but I mean, it's probably many more times to what it's last membership, you know, what's when I remember. Got it.

Yeah, I mean, our story is very similar. Like, we are Facebook group, that started in October of 2021. I first started working on the brand,

And, I mean, I audited the brand for the fair,

like, that was my first engagement with House Cloud in November or December of 2021. So like, right before, you know, and we won the business at the agency I was at, and then I started working on the brand.

So like, right before that is when the Facebook group was created, I was just created by this woman named Bobby, and she is still the owner of the group today. We actually have decided that like, we didn't want to try to take that group

and make our own group that, that we own. We thought it was better to let it continue to grow organically, and us just to have a relationship with Bobby.

So like, we have an incredible relationship with her now.

Like, we're talking to our organic social/community team, owns that relationship, and like, it's an incredible relationship, she's awesome. And yeah, it was just like, the group was started, because people wanted to talk about Hex Cloud,

and like, ask questions about the product, and how to get the best use out of it, and now it's just turned into this incredible, like, what I call like an A tier community, which is like, I think when someone,

when you have customers talking to other customers, I think that's like A tier community, and I just want to share, like, quickly screen share, 'cause I think it's really cool to look at the type of content that gets posted in here.

So it's, you know, 95,000 people strong now. It's called Click with Hex Cloud.

“If you want to join it, you can check it out,”

but like, just to share, like, why I think stuff like this

is so powerful, I think it's always,

to the extent that like, your customers can answer other customers, questions, like, I think that is a really powerful thing, and I think that speaks to like, when you have customers that are willing to answer other people's questions,

I think that speaks to like, how strong your brand is, and how, you know, sticky these people are. So just as an example, like this guy Carl yesterday, he is posting an egg video, you know, egg sticking is like one of the things that is like one

of the biggest problems in cooking on any stainless steel pan. So I won't go through all the copy, but basically he was just sharing his advice on like how to get non-stick out of the Hex Cloud pan. And then you can see there's like 31 comments here

of people just like kind of talking about like, hey, how do we, like, just collaborating on this, right? And just like giving each other advice on how to get non-stick, you know, it's all about heat and technique, you know, there's a novel in here of someone responding

to someone else that had a problem. And this is happening like multiple times a day on tons of posts, you have people posting like, what they made for dinner and then people commenting saying, hey, can I get the recipe?

Like it just has come to come this really insane customer customer community channel for us.

“And I think that's ultimately why we saw that happening”

organically, 'cause we thought like we were sitting there like, hey, should we try to take control of this group? Or should we just collaborate with the owner and let her continue to run it?

And ultimately we decided to let her continue to run it

because we didn't want it to, we just didn't want to feel like we were running it. And we feel like all of the customer customer stuff that was happening would maybe go away if all of a sudden we were the moderators

and the controllers of that group and it would just feel too brand oriented. So I think we went slightly different directions in that respect. Now we were razors edge we were close

to making drawing the same conclusion. Like I, in fact, I think I was slightly more on your side than ultimately I think it was Curtis who pushed us over the edge to own this space. I was curious to have you or anyone on the team

have you talked to that original founder and like dissect, you just got insight into like why they felt that urge to create a Facebook group around it in the first place. I just be curious if you'd got any insights from that.

- Yeah, the status wanted to connect with other people using our products. Like they had questions about how to use it. They had questions about like what people were making with it and they just wanted to communicate with other people

“that had bought hexclad and they felt like the best way”

to do that was to make a Facebook group. And we're the same as you. Like we'll put half of our budget in the matter of this year. So like it's a channel that people are already getting ads from us on.

So it made sense to make that community live in and meta. But like it was as simple as that. They just wanted to like connect and collaborate with other people that had the product and had similar experiences. - So I, tied that back to like my initial appeal

which was like don't skip this episode. Like it started with a single person, right? So one person with a level of love or curiosity or advocacy for the brand, like is enough one single person to like start that spark.

And I think that's something I hear so often from like other brands when they look at our community or they look at your communities or like how do I get started? And I'm like well step one is get started dude. Like actually do something.

There's somebody out there who loves your product give them a place to talk about it. Which it sounds like that's, I mean whether it was the single person who happened to love both of these brands for us

or was the person who started your group. Like this is not a nine figure technique. This is literally something you're gonna apply to any brand. So just tie that back. - And I think too like you don't have to take the route

we took where it happened organically

You don't own it like if you're sitting there today

and you don't have a community

and you have like an age split of your customer that they're spending their time on meta. Like you could start that group if you want in own it. And there are ways to get an initial traction.

So one thing I'd be doing is just going and looking at like what are your top 200 LTV customers and say hey we just joined this group like we would love it if you guys could join it and start to get some activity going.

Maybe you incentivize them and say hey like if you start posting in here we'll give you a discount or something. I would bet that they don't even need that.

“I think your top LTV customers are just gonna be excited”

that the brand they love is reaching out to them and asking them to participate in the community. But like that's that's as simple as that right? And I guess that's a good segue 'cause I want to talk about

actually I've got a question for you here Connor. (whooshing)

If your CFO gives you $10 million for Q4,

where do you put it? Medicine's prospecting, last clicks as branded search and outdated MMM says TV. Most marketing operators have more measurement than ever and still no decision.

More data, more dashboards, more complexity. I know we've been here at Hexclad. We have MTAs, holdout tools, MMMs and you often look at all this data and you start to analyze it.

But then you don't make that final step which is what's the decision? Like what are we doing because of all this data? That's where architect, houses new AI agent comes in.

It turns measurement into weekly recommendations, grounded in incrementality. As factors in your launches and promos, recommends where to move budget and tells you why. For I've caused Maddox got $700,000

in annualized incremental revenue from just three weeks of architect recommendations. Go to house.io/operators to start getting recommendations from architect and optimizing your Q4 ad budget today. Maybe I'm front running you a little bit,

but I would love to hear one, you kind of estimate this, but just how does Hexclad has a brand engaged with the group?

“One, are you driving people there and how do you do it?”

And then two, you just screen-shared it. And there's a lot of organic content and you described it as an AT or community of customers, talking to customers. Do you guys play a role?

Are you giving discount codes? Are you talking about early product? Are you soliciting feedback? What is your activity in the community once people are there? - Yeah, so I'll start with the activity once people are there.

It's a lot of stuff. We'll do fun competitions every now and again with a prize at the end, like, hey, whoever makes the most beautiful photo of this meal and tags us, at the end of the month, we're gonna choose a winner

and they get X, so we'll do fun engagement plays like that. We'll grab people out of the group and add them to product survey or product feedback groups to say, hey, we're developing this product, we'd love to get your feedback, like help.

So we're actually crowdsourcing product development tips from them. We're definitely doing review sourcing with that group. So our bank where launch, we actually, we talked to with 30, 40 people that were lined up

that we gave product to and they left us a candid review and then we also launched 100 units early to that group and then followed up to them with a specific review request. We will launch our sales early in there. It's not like the most effective,

but I think it just makes them feel like thought about and stuff like that. So we'll say, hey, this sales, now live, the first person to have this URL, like, oh, get what you want before anything stops out.

Yeah, that's like, those are a bunch of content pillars and ways that we're activating in there. And then as far as growth goes, we really lean into own media a lot to drive growth to this group.

So we lean about it throughout the entire journey. I actually think pushing people to a Facebook group

is an incredible thing to promote in a welcome flow.

Like, there's probably no better, like bottom of funnel tactic to someone that's been in your funnel and is thinking about what they want then to say, hey, go to our Facebook group and see what people are talking about and ask questions

and like, you're gonna get your questions answered. I think it's a very powerful way to acquire someone that's been thinking about your products. And then we're also promoting in our cross-self flows, our post-purchase flows, so it's pre and post-purchase.

We'll have what we call campaign blocks. So like, if we have a campaign that's about any topic, we can put in a little block. That's like, hey, go join our Facebook group. So all sorts of ways in our own media channels

is like the primary driver of that group's growth. - McCoy, do you guys have similar tactics or does it deviate in any meaningful way? - Yeah, almost work forward. We're probably a little bit more.

So that original premise which is in kind of described is like the A tier relationship that we agree with that 100%. Let the customers interact with the other customers. That's the best possible thing. So we are very active in the group.

We at some point decided we wanted to own that space

“because that's why that's what made us feel comfortable”

doing all the things Connor just described which is like promoting the group and our own media and pushing, like we're gonna spend a lot of time and it's a sizable investment to in your post-purchase flows

and all these things be pushing and run into a group. We want to own that group. That was just like the razor's edge decision that we made. But we're very active in the group.

One of the funny like quirky parts of our Facebook community

is originally we had made these kind of like burner accounts to help moderate the comments and things like this for my social media team. And for whatever reason, I'm not even really sure. This is, I don't know if it's tactical,

you don't need to repeat this, but in your business. But they happen to make the name of the account one of the dogs that was running around the office, like their name, another dog who was running around the office

and then they used as a profile photo, a photo of a third dog.

So it was like dog named dog named dog photo. I don't know why, that's just how we did it. But those became the moderator accounts and they've since become these like characters for the brand that are nameless and faceless like they're not

the social media hires first and last name. And so they can act in sort of like larger than life capacity because they're playing a character. And so we have probably four or five of those who all have distinct personalities

and distinct roles within the group. So like one of them is usually designated to launch sneak peeks about coming products. The other one writes poetry about current events that are happening within the brand.

One of the oldest moderators is like, wait, hold on, hold on, hold on, hold on. We gotta stop, hold on, what do you mean? Tell me more, like let's quadruple click on that.

“That's poetry, like Portland, like who's writing the poetry?”

Well, if you didn't notice, our name is Portland leather goods. So we have no shortage of writers and creative people in the city of Portland. And so we have one employee who's very fond of writing poetry and they write poetry to the customers

in the tone of their character. So like yeah, we're in the group all the time posting brand-led content, but as much as possible, we're letting them run. We're letting them have the conversations day one to have.

Good bad, whatever it may be. And then doing our best to lightly moderate those so it doesn't get out of hand, 'cause sometimes it does. But it's best if they're talking amongst themselves. OK, I've got one more question for each of you.

And then Connor, I know I sort of hijacked a few of them here, so we could take this wherever you'd like to go. But for brands, it's just starting, say, ridge. How should I be thinking about extracting-- I don't want to say extracting.

That sounds very transactional. But how should I think about generating value from the group? I'd love to hear you guys talk about that. How much is revenue?

How much is like brand value and affinity? And how much is like product feedback?

“And like how would you split that out a little bit more granularly?”

So that if a new brand like ridge is getting into this community strategy, we kind of understand where we should be investing and where we should be expecting, getting value for ourselves. I suspect Connor's going to be like, he's super tactical.

He's always super tactical.

That's what I think I love about him. So I'll go like more atmosphericy brand. Like everyone intuitively understands that it's probably a better thing than a worse thing to have a large social media following, right?

And we don't necessarily think about dissecting or getting all of those same questions or valid questions for the leader of the marketing organization wonder. A lot of those are going to happen naturally if you just do the damn thing and you build a following.

So they're going to happen organically. So for me, it'd be like what the main opportunity of this is you create another own media channel from where you can distribute messages, your product releases, whatever it is, two your top fans,

and then you can also get from them feedback about your brand, about your messaging, about your products, about whatever you choose. So like first and foremost is like before we get to that level, and again, I think Connor is going to like kick my butt

on the tactical side of this thing, is like just do it first.

Like don't worry about that. Just build, make your social media account so to speak, with launch your Instagram account. I think anyone who saw like a brand without an Instagram account, you'd be like, what are you doing?

“Like you need to give people a place to follow you.”

I think a group is no different. Whether it's Reddit, Discord, I think Met is probably the best, just for like keeping the signal where you're trying to advertise, but in any case, like just get it started, just get people having conversations first and foremost.

They don't even need to be like on the nose brand, right? I'm sure there's a lot of posts that happen like in the cooking test cloud group that are not necessarily driving home the point that this is the best pan on Earth.

And important leather goods, it's the same thing. People are talking about their life and their struggles and all of these things that are happening in the real world. In our container, and every so often, it gets pointed back to Portland.

Other goods, and that's a net benefit for us. But it's first and foremost, it's an own media channel of 200,000 plus people that when we need to, we can distribute messaging to. And when we also want to, we can pull out insights

and various pieces of information from them. They feel like it's a focus group, so to speak. So that's my initial appeal, which is like, don't worry about it. Just get it going and like that value will largely sort itself out too.

Every Q4, brands pile money into meta, compete against each other in the same auction and battle rising ad costs, where your customer's attention goes beyond just scrolling on Instagram. Holiday movies, TV shows, and football.

What if your brand showed up outside the advertising rat race,

Where the entire family is watching?

That's where neonpixel comes in.

Neonpixel gets your e-commerce brand onto premium streaming networks, including HBO Max, ADC, Paramount Plus, and tons more. They make sure your ads only show up for the house, hold you, want to target. And they connect ad views to site visits and orders.

So TV actually earns its place in your performance budget. CTV through Neonpixel is a big part of our media budget all year long at Hacks Cloud, but a special year in BFCM. Last year in 2025, we scaled our CTV budget with Neonpixel 287% in November compared to October.

But the window to launch before Black Friday inside of Monday is closing. So go to Neonpixel.co to get a free CTV plan for Q4. Yeah, OK. So I'll say my tactical thoughts. I agree with Point 1 and make the group.

“I think Point 2 is what are the content pillars, right?”

And then creating a content calendar around that. So it's like, hey, we're going to do products surveys. Great. That's one content pillar. We're going to do early access stuff.

OK, great, that's one content pillar. We're going to do like limited addition stuff for this group. We're going to do content around like FAQs that pop up over and over again. So you end up with like five, six starting piece of the content. Because I think that's where people often maybe get stock is like,

what do I even post? Like, what types of information should I put in there? And then I think just like choose the ones that make sense, right? This isn't like rocket science, right? Like you know what your customers are going to want to hear.

And then over time, you can refine those and see like, oh wow, like content pillars, A and D are really getting more engagement than C and E. So like maybe we do less of C and E and more of A and D. Like, have a calendar, at least two months out. So you're not like driving a bunch of people to this group.

And it's just kind of empty. I think that's like the starting point.

“And I think as far as growth tactics go.”

I think doing like a dedicated email sequence up front, you know, maybe this is like four to five email or SMS pushes happening over the course of a couple months. Hey, we just launched this new group. Join it if you're interested.

Here's the types of stuff will be posting. And then I think after that, obviously you don't want to have to be putting in like an email campaign dedicated to this every time you want to grow the group. So I think building it out into like an automated life cycle marketing style is really helpful. You know, I got to say we have it in our welcome flow and our post purchase flows.

We have blocks that we put it in for campaigns. And that's been able to to drive a lot of really good growth.

You know, I think the I think the group is at like 20, 30,000 when it first,

when we first like, you know, in the first like year or so, now it's at like almost 100,000. So there's a lot of really like high-intent engaged people in there. And then I think it's, I don't know, I personally, we don't try to measure too much revenue from it. Like, I would do like what obviously we're doing early access and stuff.

And we we measure revenue and orders that are coming when we do that.

“Who's to say that those people wouldn't also just have bought when we launched it publicly?”

I would bet that a lot of them would have. But I think it's like revenue growth through brand-oriented activations. Like, I do think that it has an impact on our lifetime value with our top customers. Because unless you're like really engaged with a brand, you're probably not joining that group.

And I think the more engagement that happens in that group with those people, the more likely they are to buy. And I was like, it's not like, you know, one of those things that's easy to measure. But it's, it's what, you know, um,

got a blank in the guy from nectar mattress said on like our second episode.

Yeah, Jared, it's like, don't not do good marketing just because you can't measure it that well. And I think it's this is like the great example of that. Like, it's pretty impossible to like go and comb through our posts from the last five years. And not conclude that this isn't like a really good brand. Play for us that is certainly driving increased lifetime value.

I couldn't quantify how much lifetime value it's driving. But, um, it definitely is. So I think that's, that's where I was started. Like, make the group one. Identify your content pillars to start producing content against those content pillars.

And then once you have like a build out enough calendar, maybe you start posting some content before you even drive growth to it. Um, then start like implementing those those growth marketing tactics. I think is like the three or four step approach. Can we, so who said, who said that line because they deserve all the credit in the world? That was Jared from, from nectar mattress.

He's like, and which is funny, because like there are some of the most, um, dialed in marketers from like a measurement standpoint in my opinion. Like, they, these guys are like probably at the peak, like they still like day trade media. Um, I think. And yeah, that was his, his comments.

So if he's saying that, you know, it's, it means something. I mean, hey, you were talking about quantifying, we at one point did attempt to quantify this. And we do a lot, like, and again, in my initial response, I agree everything kind of are saying. Like, there's a lot of ways in which you can assist. Matthias has like the marketing leader with your marketing team.

We, we at one point did survey, you know, the members of those group. Because it's a little hard to connect the members of the group on a Facebook list. It's not like, exportable to a customer list. But we know from the people we surveyed, which was quite a good chunk of them. Their LTV is more than 30 x their initial AOV, more than 30 x like across 250,000 members.

It's definitely propped up as I buy some whales, but, um, it's significant.

So first and foremost, just get the damn thing going.

I don't want it to get lost, too, because kind of you said something smart in the beginning,

“which if somebody's wondering like, literally, what is the first step?”

You said, just take your, your best or highest LTV customers, 200, 300, whatever sizeable chunk you have. Give them an incentive, email, or whatever, maybe not, just email them to come join the group. Like that, that's super tactical. That is literally how you get started. Don't just like wait for, you know, if, whether it's, you're sorry, my story like it all started

with some magical moment where somebody took it upon themselves. If that's not happening for you, just go do it yourself and you literally lay the grammar. That is literally exactly how you start it for anyone wondering. And I think one thing I've heard brands maybe do is get a little too precious about who they're promoting it, too. Like, oh, we only want to push it to people that have bought three or four times from us,

because we want it to be the most like high, you know, LTV, highly engaged customers. I think that you do not need to do that. And the reason I think you, you can have, like, kind of cast a water net is the people that do where don't engage in that group and join it, they kind of self-select. Like, anyone that's not interested or isn't going to engage or they're probably not going to join that group.

“So, like, I don't think you have to be worried about, like, casting too wide of a net.”

Like, you know, if you're a rich and you, and you're up, you know, two or three and a million dollar

brand and you have, like, tens of millions of customers, I, like, wouldn't be too worried about, oh, I don't want to send this push to people that only bought from us once in the last six months. Because, like, again, anyone that is in that cohort, if they see this push and they're like, hey, that's interesting to me, or no, that's not interested to me. They're going to join or they're not going to join. And I think you're, it's almost going to self-select for people that are going to want to engage with that group.

So, I think you can, like, cast a wider net up front than I've heard a lot of people, like, oh, I'm only promoting this to like, people that have bought three times for us. It's like, well, you want those people that haven't bought as many times to be in there as well. So, the people that have bought three or four times can get those people that I have only bought once. They're having bought it all to buy for the first time or the second or the third time.

So, it's like, it does turn into this, like, really interesting. Like, it's a middle-bottom of funnel play on first-time orders. It's a post-purchase, like, wind-back play. Like, there's so many people in different stages and you're just allowing your customers to get that person in the bottom of funnel to buy for the first time or to get that person that's bought once to buy second time or whatever it is.

“So, I think, like, get a lot of people in there, no matter where they live in your, in your, like, journey or in, like, their customer cycle.”

McCoy, where does it sit in the org at PLG? Like, is it? Because I'm, here you guys discuss it, and I'm, like, I could see it being a social thing, like a social media manager thing. I could see it being a CX thing. I could even see it being, like, a real, like, retention thing.

Someone on the email, SMS, direct mail, can be managing the meta group. So, how do you guys approach it? Most brands treat customer support as a cost, but with AI, every support conversation is now a chance to increase retention. Recover revenue and grow your LTD. Rich panel doesn't just use AI to answer tickets.

They allow operators to run revenue experiments inside your support. You can test different windback offers on refund requests. Subscriptions save offers during cancellations and product recommendations that turn chats into sales. Plus, they guarantee you're going to save money. 50% of your support volume automated in 30 days or your money back.

That's a pretty good offer, if you ask me. So, at richpanel.com/demo, they'll build an AI support team live for your business. And show you how it can drive incremental revenue for you.

It sits first and foremost with the social team.

But all of those other teams have massive overlap and your intuition is correct. Like, they care a lot about what's going on there. So, we have some CX agents who work inside the group under, like, very, like, obvious CX or, you know, moderator names. And then our retention specialists and the retention team cares deeply about what's going on in there. For the other reasons you just described.

There's so much, I mean, the primary thing that's coming out of that is returning customer revenue. Like, new customer revenue is much harder to measure the impact of it out. But once you know someone's in the group and then you can start to, like, model their behaviors. As I mentioned, we know who's in there in large part retention teams care a lot about that. But it's all generally obviously going to sit underneath your marketing org.

But I think social is probably the best home for it. Because, I mean, we've hit on it indirectly several times. It's like, you don't want to be too salesy and brand forward in there. That's not the point. It's not an ad.

Like, it's not that common for it on our original ad. It's a community. So, like, treat it like a community. Do cool stuff and risk just plenty of it. People are going to want to talk about that.

People are going to want to talk about their experience with the product. And your main KPI here is conversation, not sales. Like, that's my honest opinion. You main KPI is, do people want to come back to this place to host or to have conversations? Without the people, maybe with the brand, but it's not an ad.

It's not an ad channel. It's an own media channel. Yes, but you want conversations first and foremost.

So, Connor, where are you guys at?

It sounds like you're scheming right now.

Want to get something going.

“Like, where, what are your thoughts on what you're going to do or what you're not going to do?”

Yeah, no. I wouldn't even put myself in the scheming. Where I'm at right now, yeah, I'm not even in the scheming stage here. You know, right now, it's we're in the middle of Q4. I've been building out my list.

I spend most of Q4 just developing really large lists of things that we potentially We want to do in 2027. I don't spend the next couple weeks, like sort of finding it from there. And this will make it onto the list. I'm listening to this podcast right now.

As a, as a unbiased non community-pilled marketer. I'm like, all right. I'm community curious is where I would say. I'm in the, I'm in the funnel. No, the, you know, the one thing Connor, you mentioned we had Ariana on from half days.

Fantastic brand extremely community-pilled. Very active Slack group. They do IRL activations.

It is like a huge part of their sort of growth mechanic.

And one thing that she said, and this is me like partially coping for not having a community ourselves. One thing she said on the podcast was, you really have to understand who you are as a brand. And what is your consumers or your customers relationship to your brand? And how valuable is it to be leaning into community?

And I do think there's something to be set around like the importance of community is extremely highly correlated with repeat purchase rate. Every single day in our international markets. We have like on days 92% of revenue coming from new customers. We are so incredibly new customer acquisition oriented that the community play is like,

especially for our size, no doubt can be additive. It is something that I should be thinking about. Therefore, it's a making my 2027 list of things to consider. But I also think from a priority perspective. It's just not as impactful as other tactics might be.

And from a team perspective like our bandwidth is finite. And it's one of the reasons I asked about where it sits within the org, because we don't even have like a dedicated organic social person. Like a social media manager will definitely make that higher in Q1. But even that feels to me more like a top of funnel content entertainment role at this point.

Then it is like community management. I almost feel like those are deviating in my mind in terms of who manages what within an org. So that's where I'm at currently. As I think Ridge sits in a slightly different position than a hexclad and a Portland leather goods. We're going to try to prioritize based on that.

But up until this point, I've at least convinced myself and the team that we should be spending our time elsewhere. I'm going to push you on it. I think you might be internalizing it a little too much. Like, hey, this is not the highest leverage activity for me personally.

And I think you're right. I suspect you probably don't spend a ton of time on SEO every day, right? Right. Like this idea, okay. This is a thing that's going on in the background.

It's not my job every day. But it's someone's job. And it's going to take years of compounding growth stacked for this thing to be. Additive and important to our business. And now if you're S if all of our SEO disappeared tomorrow,

we all know that what happened impact on the business. So it's like it may be worth putting a butt in a seat. And like starting this thing, it's going to start slow.

But if it never starts and it never materializes,

unless it just magically explodes one day. And that's not likely going to happen to you, meaning whoever the audience is listening to this. It's not going to happen. It's just wake up and there's 100,000 group talking about your product.

So get it going the same way you think about SEO slow burn. But it's not the most important thing for you to do every day. I 100% agree. But is it high enough leverage to put a butt in a chair and have more content slowly? I think so.

“Yeah, and that's what it's on the 2027 things for sure.”

But like let's say if it's bridge in 2019, I think the answer's no. Is it worth a butt in the seat? Like you know, it's like I said at this point, like rich will do over $200 million is here.

It's like, okay, yeah, for sure we can afford a butt in a seat to have this small compounding thing. And I hear all your guys' points. Product feedback alone could pay multitudes over time. Like it's not that much of an investment.

But that's really relative to our size. Then it is like strategically important for the growth of the business. If we were in a less mature state. Yeah, for sure. If you're already doing social media management,

this is a very small offshoot from that. Like if you have somebody who's moderating or like you probably have some forced moderating the comments on your ads, right? Maybe it's an A obot or something like that. But like if you have somebody there,

this is just creating that container for conversation. Doesn't take much of their time to the point when it is small. Like you don't need someone working at full-time. If there is only 200 members in there.

“But the only way to get to 406 and blah, blah, blah,”

and compounds all the way to where you get to is if you actually start. So I totally understand like resource allocation and things like that when you're small. It's really hard to stretch imagination there. And which is why I think a lot of people don't have this.

But at some point I think it's definitely worth considering. We also like, you know, to go back to your original question of like, where does this sit? It sits under our social team, our organic social team.

But we are actively hiring for a community manager, because we do want someone to fully focus on this group,

On Reddit, on some other community-based channels that we,

that we think that we can make a bigger impact on.

“Like, you know, we thought about launching Reddit ads.”

And we've ultimately decided not to right now,

just because like we don't think we have the organic management happening there yet to warrant it. And I just think if we start generating demand in there, we don't also have the organic stuff taken care of. It's probably not going to work as well as we wanted to.

The other thing I want to go back on with half days is, you know, McCoy and I, like, our brands, our Facebook group is there for a reason. Like, that community is on Facebook for a reason, because like, we skew older.

Like, if you were to look at our age split, it's concentrated in an older demographic, and that older demographic, they spend their time on Facebook. So we are building that community where our audience spends their time.

Half days, I would bet their concentration of of of demo is women 25 to 40 or 25 to 35. I would bet that a lot of those women are working remote jobs,

or if they're not working remote jobs,

they are working in some sort of role that involves a lot of computer work. And their company communication channel is Slack. So it makes a lot of sense for half days to have their community live in Slack because that, because their core demo is already spending their time there. You know, they also have, I joined this like,

Instagram group that they started as well. And same thing, right? Like, their audience is spending their time on Instagram. Like, we could probably do that, but it's definitely not where our core audience is.

Like, I don't think it would make sense for us to have a Slack community. So I think if you're listening to this, just 'cause like McCoy and I have our groups living in Facebook, that doesn't necessarily mean that's where your group should live.

“Like, you need to think about where does your group spend their time?”

And that's where you should have your community live, because you want to make it seamless to engage with the community group. Like, if you're a half-day customer and you're 28 years old and you're a graphic designer for a marketing agency, like you're opening up Slack every single morning.

So like, you have that half-day group chat. You're going to see the notification starts stacking up, and you're going to go and see what's going on. You know, so like, it's the same thing with, you know, our audience is scrolling through a meta and like,

looking at, you know, pictures of their brothers, kids, or whatever. And like, they're also going to see the notifications from the Facebook group. When they're doing that. So I think just thinking about where you're already in spend your time and not assuming that, you know, just because Brand A, Brand B,

or Brand C has their group in a certain spot, is also where your community should live is. It's just like, you got to be thoughtful about where that community lives. Connor, do you guys do any sort of IRL activations? And the reason I ask is another point from the half-days one,

is so interesting, right? Because they are like a ski and snow apparel. And so customers of half-days have a shared passion, sort of like intrinsically. So like they have the Slack group.

They have it based by city. They do these. They have these ambassadors. They bring people out. They do, you know, app risk,

app risk activities on, on the weekends and things. Really, really cool way to bring in online community offline. Hex God seems somewhat similar in the sense that like, those people commenting in your group are like passionate about cooking. They obviously love the Hex God Hex Cloud product.

But there's almost like in additional sort of interest and activity that they all share. So do you see these people meeting up offline? Is that something that you encourage? Could you see yourself doing it in the future? At John's Road, we needed thousands of new ads every month.

Daily emails, lots of creative as well. We needed great people that had really high standards, but we had bootstrap company on a budget. And that is why we were propelled to recruit our team for us. They are specialists in recruiting marketing and operations people from Latin America.

And they work with the best brands and agencies in e-com. They charge a one-off fee once you hire. They're no recurring charges or ongoing fees. They also offer a three month guarantee on all new hires. Plus you can get 10% off your first hire

when you go to we are propelled.com/operators. Yeah. I wouldn't say we do it to the level that half days does it. You know, half days they're doing like, hey, we're going on a morning lock.

We're going on a morning hike in this city. Like, let's meet up.

“Like, I think that stuff's really cool and really powerful.”

And it's also like relatively low lift. I think maybe a misconception is if you're going to host an IRL event that it has to be this like big production and like expensive. And a lot going on. Like it literally only has to be an ambassador from the brand.

Being like the point person or like the voice of that brand. And like a party full event, right? Like it can be as low lift as that.

And I think that's totally powerful.

Again, that's like a tier community customer stuff. We do it. You know, we're doing more and more of our own events. An example that's top of mind for me right now is we won. We just did a couple of weeks ago for our bake where we launched bakeware.

And the middle of September. And then we did. We're doing some out of home for it in New York and L.A. And part of that out of home activation was in New York and L.A. for a weekend.

We, it's called like the secret oven. And we basically did a collaboration with last crime. They made a custom cookie.

We were giving away free cookies as a way to like show our bakeware to the wo...

And then we drove a bunch of traffic from our own list to that event. So like we went and basically made segments of people in L.A. And in New York and said, hey, this is going on on this day. And it worked really well. We had lines around the corner pretty much all day, especially in New York.

So yeah, we're doing we're doing stuff like that. But that was a huge production. Like that was a multiple hundred thousand dollar production. Now again, it's, it's a big out of home activation too. It's not only the experiential bit.

Um, I think where we can get better is doing more of like the lower lift. Like half days ask stuff like, hey, we have like, you know, a cooking class happening in this city on this day. It's ten dollars to join like come hang out.

You know, I think stuff like that is is really powerful.

And, um, you know, the thing that that Ari said on that episode that really made, that really stuck with me is like, when you're deciding if you want community to be a big pillar of your brand,

“you have to ask like, does it make sense for your brand and what you're offering?”

So, you know, Ari's whole thesis is that like, you know, there's a barred entry to skiing. If you're a female that wants to get into the sport. It's expensive. There's not a lot of like clothing or outer outerwear gear that was built for like the audience that half day is targeting.

So that's why the brand, um, ultimately started and like it's really helpful for those people to like, engage and communicate with and not one another because they have similar share problems and experiences. Same with same with tax cloud. Like, cooking is a very, you know, community based engagement base thing. So it makes sense for us.

But if you're selling like, I don't know, fidget spinners. Like, there's really not a community play there. Or if you're selling, you know, weighted blankets. There's probably not as big of a community play.

“So I think, you know, not every person listening their brand is going to have a product that makes sense for community.”

But I think if there's like a shared experience that there should be a dialogue or communication around between your customers. I think that's where it makes sense to do community and how like community like growth as a pillar of your brand. Right.

And the thing that I would add here that I always think is really interesting and is like, under discussed.

This is this is also like capital and marketer, uh, sort of topic here. Um, but it's like what you're also describing Connor is the mission of the company. Right. So I don't know half days, but if y'all raven another outdoor apparel brand. Um, the mission of their company is to inspire the world to walk with nature. It's like, okay, if that is your mission, then it will help you design certain clothes.

But it will also, from a social perspective, it's like, yeah, we want to bring people together and get them outside doing things. Like, there's an almost natural sort of progression into how it becomes community. For Ridge, our mission is create innovative functional products designed in the last for life. It's very product oriented. It's very, we are doing a thing and we are delivering those products. And it doesn't as naturally become community at that point.

Um, again, that's like, that's like a part of how at least we prioritize it internally.

“So McCoy, I'm curious, do you guys have a mission of our leather goods and do you feel like it plays any sort of role in your approach to community?”

Short answer.

No, not one that we put into words like we want to make great products with this amazing material.

You know, we've dedicated ourselves to calling or we've dedicated our name to being Portland leather. Um, I don't know that that's like the exact tie to why the community, our community specifically is so large. Um, for us, that what's been incredibly transformative and how we've gotten people in real life, although that that was happening, we were doing IRL meetups before this, our major retail expansion, but it really was the major retail expansion that got people to meet together.

I think it would go back to like, we are not on this level, but you think about like the inception and the creation of like Disneyland. It's this idea where like you're sitting at home watching cartoons and fairy tales. And there's nothing like, I don't know necessarily like community orientated around that, but then all of a sudden they create a vessel for enthusiasm, right? They create this place where you can go in and in all of a sudden what was personal and you watched on your home screen was physical and real.

And people could meet and share their enthusiasm for this thing. And so I think that that's a template that more brands can take, even if they're not necessarily like mission oriented. It's like, I mean, there's a lot of nerdy people out there, if they like fidget spinners, it could be just a group for nerds period and fidget spinners are things that combine them, right? The shared experience, as you mentioned, of like whatever that product is.

But for us, like we're doing, the we're doing a map, we're in the middle of a massive retail expansion. We're on the road to 50 stores. And that has become like our Disneyland, like, as I mentioned, IRL meetups were happening beforehand. What am I favorite things to do is like when I'm tossing around these questions, I go into our insider's group, or in other insiders, and I just search search certain keywords.

So I'm going to like test out my ability to actually share screen share on this podcast or whatever. I think I got it. Let's go here. So anyways, I just search like the word meet up here and like scroll through our group.

Whether it's people like in the store or just taking photos like in the store.

Or just meeting up outside of the store and having like private parties, like there is a lot going on here.

“And so I think the physical world is a very good place to bring your brand into.”

Like it's really what takes this atmospheric e-commerce company and it brings it into the physical world. Like you see this, even with products that I think are like incredibly expensive are hard to like necessarily create. Repurchase, like cars, cars are a big thing. Like you're not going out buying like a ram truck every day, but there's truck meetups all over the country. And it's your shared experience with the product that you, you know, you purchase. And it's a vessel for that advocacy. Go to cars and coffee every Saturday or whatever it is.

So yeah, we're doing a lot of the in real life stuff. It's been happening for a long time that will continue for a long time. And that's, I mean, hey, these are real people. Real people exist inside of real physical world and meeting a bunch of them and surrounding yourself with like minded people. And you have the shared passion for this product or this thing or this group or this cartoon.

“Whatever it is, like in real life, I think is an exceptional place to start even small, even in your local territory with your best customers.”

I, again, I'm going to push. I'm going to be the very pro community, very pro like IRL event type person because I just saw how much the brand shifted for us. When we went from an e-commerce company to having a physical store, people would walk in the room and there was just this sort of pause every customer would take. They walk in the room and they stop like two, three feet into the doorway. And they look around and I was like, what is that moment that they, that they're doing there? What's happening inside their brains?

And I'm like, oh, yeah, I'm the dumb ads guy. I'm the technical marketer here. And when somebody comes into my storefront, they come in often add and they're typically laying on like a PDP where they're looking at one product, one color, one variant, have a time. And I was saying they walked in and they can see everything in all the colors and all the options and all the things. And it's like, it's their Disneyland, it's there where whatever analogy you want to use.

Get people, maybe retail stores are not right for you, but like IRL meetups if you can, if your brand can do it, I think is exceptionally powerful.

Even if it's just, but I mean, who knows, like whatever your product category is, there's probably a larger community that you yourself belong into. Like you're probably didn't create the first product in a net new category. So cooking, we're not the first one to create pans, but you can place yourself in a larger community of people who cook. That's a good idea. It doesn't necessarily have to be about the exact reaction to your exact product. And it also doesn't even need to be with like for us, we have a super long consideration period.

So like if we were to say, hey, we're hosting a cooking class in LA on this day. It's $10 to attend. It's going to be fun. We're going to have this creator influencer there, leading it, whatever it is. I can't think of like a better touch point to have with someone that has signed up for our own media list, but I didn't convert it yet. Like they're going to get the product in their hands. They're going to have a fun time. They're going to talk to other customers.

Like it really does become a really good touch point from all the way from the top of the funnel to the first touch point all the way to the person making their their 10th order.

“Like it's one of the, I think it's a, there's not a ton of channels that are like that where the experience is really good for anyone no matter where they're at in the journey.”

Totally. Okay, so we spent a lot of time today talking about like, how how McCoy and in myself are activating our community is we're talking about, you know, Conners kind of starting to noodle on the idea of building more community at a ridge with some like dedicated groups and how we would go about that. But a lot of people listening, they don't have these community groups yet and whether or not they want to start them or not. And if they do want to start them like there's going to be a little bit of a ramp up here, but there's so many other ways to

You know, allow your happy satisfied customers to just spread the the word about your brand so I want to spend like the last 10 minutes here just talking about like tactically what are what are ways that you can like help or incentivize your your customers to spread the word about your brand. That's like not a Facebook group or a Slack community or discord group so. Yeah, Connor, maybe I'll start with you. Do you have any thoughts on on that like how brands can incentivize satisfied customers to help.

Acquire more customers. We talk a lot about cat on this show. You can't control what Meditarges you, but you can control what happens after someone lands on your site. That's where our sponsor after sell comes in helping you make every visitor worth more from cart offers and one click post purchase upsells to subscription upgrades. And here's the best part rock. Thanks. Turns your confirmation page into another revenue stream with cross brand upsells. With earnings save those earnings also offset your after sell subscription dollar for dollar and you get to keep your entire payout.

Had to after sell dot com slash earn dash save to see what after sell could unlock for your business and how you could get the entire software for zero dollars a month. Yeah, it's a great question. Um, if I, we have a ton of happy customers. How do we how do we sort of parlay that into them sharing their advocacy and using that to convert new customers in the future?

Um, you know, I think there's some obvious ones.

And there's like a more authentic form of UGC that you could be soliciting like we as an example.

Um, our wedding band business. We recently had people submit their wedding photos. So we had a lot of like rich ring photos from their wedding photographers, which was super super cool.

“And we got to like reshare that. And I think it was a really cool moment sort of like close loop between like people are purchasing this wedding band product from us online.”

They're having this very special moment. Another able to kind of share that back and we're able to make that sort of a self reinforcing funnel in many ways. And just sort of like highlight the sheer amount of people who are having a similar sort of experience. Um, so that's one that I really like like actual authentic user generated content, not the UGC that we've come to know it today.

Um, that probably would be number one. I mean, I think there are clever things to do with product reviews as well.

This is very popular in like the outdoor space and sort of like the more I see it a lot with like some of the more technical bags and things. Um, but really getting like respected customers to do detailed reviews and then using that as sort of like marketing material back to prospects and other customers.

“I think it's really valuable. She's figuring out where people are passionate and turning that energy into.”

Uh, I guess the common thread there is turning that that passion and interest into like more robust authentic user generated content. Yeah, I agree with that. I think, uh, I have this brand that I used to work at when I was at home. Instead, called click. I don't know if you guys are familiar. They're reading glasses. They like come apart. So you can just let them sit on your shoulders and then when you need them, you'll you'll put them back together. And this was in, you know, 2020. So this is really when in the US like UGC was the hot thing and like it could totally turn an account around and naturally we were having a hard time finding, you know,

50, 60, 70 year old creators on all these like new UGC platforms that were connecting creators to brand. So we incentivized people to leave us a video review. I forget I think we gave him a discount code for the next order because a lot of people were buying like a pair to have at home and a pair to have the office so that offer made sense. But we got so much UGC from that activation. I'll tell you what, like I don't think any of it really worked on its own because these are like not content creators.

But when you activate that much content from your customers at volume, you can usually put some really compelling ads together that come off very authentic with a really good editor. And like some of our best ads were of these men and women sharing like just uploading their videos to a Google, a Google folder and we cut some really good ads. I think that's a, that's a great one. I think another one that's a little bit of a newer tactic is using a tool like outer signal to see who is buying from you or organically that's a content creator.

It's like, hey, who should we go activate with? Well, the person that already bought from you that has 15,000 followers on Instagram and is making really good like camera to face content and like really good product content maybe already. That's a great person to make ads for you because they bought it organically. They're probably going to leave you a very authentic review and make a really authentic ad. You don't even have to brief them that much. I think that's a really good use case for tool like that.

I think contests are like an amazing way to help your customer share your brand like, hey, we're doing a giveaway at the end of the month, whoever posts like the most beautiful image of their Thanksgiving meal and tags us.

We're going to choose three winners and those three winners are going to go to 12 piece sadly. That's an incredible way to incentivize your customers to go and spread the word.

And then like more obvious ones I guess are just referral programs like they work and they're around for a reason and you know the way that I think about our referral program is as long as the discount that we're giving to the prospect is marginally stronger than like our blended cac or I'll take that all day long like I'll give someone a hundred bucks off their first order all day long if our blended cac is at a hundred twenty because that is marginally better than what I would have to pay someone on meta ads or whatever to get them to convert.

So I think that that's a good way to get some you know incentivization to have your customers refer people and then we do a lot of like GWP in our referral program or not even with purchase just just G just gifts. So like if I send McCoy a referral link you know McCoy is getting a discount that is going to be marginally better than our blended cac and then that person who sent McCoy that discount is going to get a free gift. And then they can get up to five free gifts and then after that we post them into our like social affiliate program.

I think those are all like very clever ways to allow your customers to go acquire more customers. McCoy you got any any for us. I mean like okay so I'll put this way you probably if you're a brand you have happy customers.

“Two things I think are very important ask for what you want to receive and then use it.”

Okay so if you're on Instagram like I just the background I went to all of our Instagrams. You're getting tagged in photos whether it's like on the feed which is a little bit more rare or if you're getting tagged in stories like number one ask for what you want to receive.

Tell your customers tag us if you're going to review like I went to same thin...

All of our review sections contain photos like there's hundreds and thousands of photos of.

Port leather bags or people cooking heads hot pans or people posting their ridge wall that's UTC those are happy customers if you advertise that to the world but this is a normal behavior you happy with this product.

“So what should you do with it you should go share it and then he was the brand are taking those happy customers and advertising those to more happy customers you will get more of what you encourage so.”

If you're fashion brand I think is really easy.

Tell people to you know tag you in their stories and when they do it faithfully reposted your audience if that fits for you like people love that type of social validation. So it's not so much of a mystery to me like you you have happy customers if you ask them to post or leave reviews and all those are UTCs and then you advertise that behavior to other customers you'll get more of that behavior typically speaking otherwise maybe have a problem and everything this. That's the best and easiest way to start so like your brand today you have an Instagram or Facebook whatever it is go look through your tag photos go look through your story mentions and if there are none start asking people for it start asking your best customers which is again super tackle tip you mentioned at the top corner ask your best people so that you can advertise that behavior something you want to see more of.

I see this.

“So often there's one thing I work through my social team there's brands much much much smaller than ours as far as total customer size product sold household penetration right you name it.”

And their social media following is so much bigger and people are reposting them and that's a curious thing you're like why how are they getting more total.

Social interaction and community interaction with less customer list because the tactical marketer means it's like those things should obviously be connected right. More people have my products in there so why why is my social following not as big and oftentimes it comes down to like well they're encouraging that behavior. The reposting everyone who posts a picture in their hat or vest or they repost their product they're incentivizing it may be financially in percent off or referral codes all these things but at the point is just like most of the things aren't a mystery you just have to like.

Try them and they take a long time to build that's that's totally true and it drives the tactical marketer me and crazy because I want to put money into the machine and see more money come out everyday that's a super nice behavior but. There's lots of things that you can do and the stuff is probably already happening in your brand first and foremost ask for what you want to receive and then to use that media once you get it to market that to other customers. Yeah people love that they love like pulling up their Instagram and be like oh wow this brand I love reposted me that's cool that makes me like them even more it's like just like a simple thing but it's a nice.

“I hope I mean hit for that that person that got reposted all right we're at an hour here but and I want to go deeper on this I think this might be a separate episode but just to like tip of the iceberg.”

I want to do an over underrated on one thing for for both of you right now. I'm sorry with you overrated underrated or correctly rated loyalty programs overrated overrated I'm saying overrated to McCoy I'm saying massively underrated I. I will take you all both to church in school at the same time on loyalty programs later okay well this is this is the cliffhanger this is the cliffhanger today's episode because we we're in on a time today but I think we'll do another episode on. I respect of my perspective and Congress respect on the little two programs McCoy's perspective on loyalty programs and we can get to the bottom of the the value added loyalty programs versus the the non value added loyalty programs.

All right I don't know how I became the antagonist but maybe it fits Connor and Connor versus McCoy will see how it goes this is this is great I like it I like how this is shaping up.

Keep reading