The DTC Podcast
The DTC Podcast

How Heart & Soil's CEO Uses AI Agents to Hold Himself and His DTC Team Accountable

1d ago42:427,886 words

The Podafi briefing · AI analysis

Heart & Soil Tests Demographic UGC and AI Leadership Audits

5 min brief · 3 takeaways · Based on this episode’s transcript

The 30-second brief

TL;DR
  • 01Internal video hit an efficiency wall, prompting a shift to demographic-specific UGC despite unresolved profit concerns.
  • 02Feeding AI organizational data revealed the CEO's habit of solving team problems was reducing staff accountability.
  • 03Launching a new product on Cyber Monday aims to protect margins against holiday discounting and macro spending shifts.

The big picture

Heart & Soil shifted from internal video to demographic-specific UGC to reach new audiences, though profit impacts remain uncertain. Simultaneously, the CEO used AI to analyze internal communications, discovering his habit of solving team problems reduced organizational accountability and skewed the say-do ratio.

Useful for: DTC founders and marketing leaders looking to optimize creative testing and improve team accountability using AI.

Synthesis of podcast conversations. Speaker claims are not independently verified.

01Creative Strategy

Demographic UGC Bypasses Algorithmic Walls

Dean Salardino noted Heart & Soil hit an efficiency wall with internal video. The algorithm failed to match their messaging to the right audience. They shifted to Tribe to source specific demographics, like a 50-year-old woman speaking directly to peers.

Why it matters. Matching exact demographic personas in creative can improve ad relevance and reach audiences internal teams cannot authentically represent, potentially lowering acquisition costs.

Your next move · Podafi’s suggestion

Identify one customer persona your internal team cannot authentically represent. Source UGC creators matching that exact demographic for a controlled creative test.

The catch. UGC platforms charge significant fees or take gross merchandise value cuts. Dean noted he does not love how this line item currently impacts his profit and loss statement.

Transcript evidence

From the transcript

“they're not sending a 20-year-old female talking about her package. They're not putting that in front of the mom who's 50 and struggling with whatever she's struggling with”
Read the source transcript ↗

From the transcript

“I don't love it right now. And I'm thinking more, some of the creator stuff on TikTok shop, I haven't quite figured that out where I'm happy with what it looks like on the P&L”
Read the source transcript ↗

Evidence summary · paraphrased

Heart & Soil transitioned from internal video to Tribe because algorithms were not serving their internal team content to the correct demographics, like 50-year-old mothers.

02Operations

AI Audits Leadership Accountability

Dean fed an AI model all company meeting transcripts, emails, and project data to find organizational patterns. The AI revealed that when he jumped in to solve team problems, it became his plan, which reduced the team accountability and agency to solve issues themselves.

Why it matters. Founders solving frontline problems creates a bottleneck and prevents teams from developing ownership. Tracking a say-do ratio can highlight where execution is failing due to leadership interference.

Your next move · Podafi’s suggestion

Feed your recent meeting transcripts and project updates into a large language model. Ask it to identify instances where you or other leaders bypassed the assigned owner to solve a problem.

The catch. AI can hallucinate patterns if the prompt lacks context. Dean customized his AI with specific leadership principles from a book to guide the analysis.

Transcript evidence

From the transcript

“when the plan is successful and works, you've solved the problem, and when it doesn't work, well, it's your plan that failed, which reduces the amount of accountability and agency that somebody has with actually solving it”
Read the source transcript ↗

From the transcript

“I've tried to build essentially an organizational context layer and a scorecard system for myself as a CEO and for the organization where it's taking the data from meetings, it's taking my interactions, and it's scoring based on a number of factors, like I have the say-do ratio”
Read the source transcript ↗

Evidence summary · paraphrased

Dean Salardino used an AI model to analyze company communications and discovered his habit of jumping in to solve team problems was reducing staff accountability and skewing the say-do ratio.

03Promotions

New Product Launches Protect Holiday Margins

Instead of discounting existing inventory, Heart & Soil is launching a new whole-food electrolyte product on Cyber Monday. Dean noted this targets the existing customer base with a new offer, avoiding the margin compression that comes from discounting staples during heavy promotional periods.

Why it matters. Relying solely on discounts during the fourth quarter can train customers to wait for sales, eroding contribution margins. New product launches maintain full price integrity while still driving holiday revenue.

Your next move · Podafi’s suggestion

Identify one complementary product you can develop and launch specifically for a major holiday shopping event to avoid discounting your core catalog.

The catch. New product launches carry inventory and development risk. Dean noted they tested the waters with a small VIP batch first to gauge demand before the full Cyber Monday rollout.

Transcript evidence

From the transcript

“I'm very excited, one, because we're watching a product on Cyber Monday. So something we haven't done before, and so I'm really excited to have a new offer on Cyber Monday. That's really going to, it's going to hit hard with our existing customer base.”
Read the source transcript ↗

Evidence summary · paraphrased

Heart & Soil is launching a new whole-food electrolyte product on Cyber Monday to engage existing customers without discounting their core catalog during the heavy promotional holiday period.

From listening to doing

Take one idea into the week

Suggested experiments, not proven results. Choose what fits your brand.

Test Demographic UGC Match

  1. 01Identify a core customer persona your internal team cannot authentically represent.
  2. 02Source UGC creators matching that exact demographic and produce video ads.
  3. 03Run these ads against your current internal team videos using identical media budgets.

Measure: Compare cost per acquisition and return on ad spend between the demographic UGC and internal video cohorts.

Guardrail: Stop the test if the UGC platform fees or gross merchandise value cuts reduce overall campaign profitability below your baseline internal video margin.

Context & limitations
  • Dean Salardino explicitly stated he does not love how the UGC platform currently impacts his profit and loss statement, noting the jury is still out on its efficiency.
  • The AI leadership audit relies on feeding sensitive internal communications to a third-party model, which may violate company data security policies.

Listen to the conversation

0:000:00
Original episode description

How do you use AI to make a DTC team more accountable? Dean Brennan, CEO of Heart & Soil, built ELLIS, an AI scorecard and context layer for himself and his team. He now runs agents that spot problems in Slack, pull the data and post the answer before anyone on the team has finished digging. It started when Dean fed AI a year or two of his meetings, email, Slack and Asana, and it showed him he...

Transcript

EN

We shot of a cannon, organically, we didn't have one paid ad for probably two...

Three years in, we were close to 50 million in top line. You were like, how did you guys do it to do it? The one thing I say is like, you'd see this triangle, quality, speed, cost. The hard rule was you could only pick two. Now that triangle, you can get all three.

I fed an AI model, all of my contacts, all the meeting transcripts, my emails, our project management system, Slack. I essentially wanted to use it as a mirror and it came back with some surprising findings. This episode is brought to you by TripleWail, the AI operating system for e-commerce. Just a quick gut check for brand owners and media buyers.

“Have you started your Black Friday Cyber Monday planning yet?”

If the answer is not yet, you're not alone.

But the brands that win BFCM aren't the ones scrambling in November. They're the ones planning right now. And here's why it matters. BFCM keeps getting more expensive. Last year, ads been climbed faster than demanded, CPMs went up, and the season stretched

from a single weekend into a full month of promotions. Show up unprepared and you spend more to reach the same shoppers right when your margin matters the most. TripleWail built a free resource to help the BFCM hub. It's like a command center for planning your most profitable Black Friday with everything

in one place. Real benchmarks from tens of thousands of brands so you know what performance should actually look like for brands just like yours. Free tools, to set goals, and forecast outcomes, strategy guides, and checklists covering ad performance, retention, and conversion.

An AI powered tactics you can put to work before BFCM week hits. The best part, it's completely free and there's no log in required. Go to triplewail.com/bfcm26 and start building towards your most profitable Black Friday Cyber Monday today.

It's the D2C podcast and after a couple of years of going back and forth, I've finally got

Dean on the podcast from Heart and Soil. Welcome, man. It's great to have you. Yeah, it's been a while. You know, we've been going back and forth for about two years.

So glad to see it. Right. We could finally make this work. Anyone needs to tell us a part. I'm the bald guy with a beard with the D2C on the head, you're the other guy.

We have a similar a similar profile, which I appreciate. Amazing. So I know you've told it before on podcast, but give me a bit. Just tell me your condensed hero's journey with Heart and Soil. Yeah, I've taken a very non-traditional route to being a co-founder CEO at a supplement

company.

“I was previously in a filmmaking, content creation, and I think like most really great”

things that are built, they're built through a passion. I don't really love that word all the time, but I guess a real pain point in problem. And you mentioned the bald head earlier, I'm somebody that, you know, had suffered from autoimmune issues like Alephacia on my head, or also of Colitis, which I noticed that I had in my 20s, which caused a bunch of health issues.

And at the time, you wouldn't have even known at all that I had health issues. I was an athlete, most people were like, man, you're the healthiest guy on the planet. But my journey kind of took me into that realm, where I figured out that after being prescribed a bunch of medication, that eating real food, who would have put a thought, the food that we ate way long ago before we had a bunch of processed stuff in our diets,

and we lived a different way. Who would have known that that would have healed a lot of my symptoms and underlying condition that I had.

So long story short, man, on the side of a filmmaking and content career, I always pursued

health, ended up in the right place at the right time. And liver was actually one of the, one of the things that really helped me in my health journey. And I always took, I took liver supplements prior to starting heart and soil with Dr. Paul Saladino.

And yeah, right place right time, ran into him in a sauna in Austin, which is kind of wild and I had, you know, I was pretty connected in the health space because I was in it. And we decided to launch a company, and I helped him take it from square one, the day of launch, I was packing supplements, what wasn't in my current role.

I worked for free for three months, Joel's story there, and eventually took over the company the operations, and I've been running it for about six years. I had an English teacher in grade 11, tell me one time, very sort of conspiratorially. He was an organic farmer, and he said, now more than ever, you are what you eat.

“And I think I've thought really stuck with me over the years, especially as this like”

health revolution has kind of really kicked in, give me, because I don't like liver. I don't like, this is not, this is not a very mature taste standpoint to have on this podcast. Never like liver. Why is it important that humans consume that kind of, what's the category?

It's called glandular, glandular, why must humans consume glandular products?

Yeah, so I could go down a whole rabbit hole about what is in the organs, but essentially

“if we just backed up, I think real food is the answer, right?”

I could get so stuck on organs, real food in general is what helped me with my health conditions, it's just that organs are so nutrient-packed, and we've evolved for a long time as humans as people, and back in the day when we would hunt often times, the leader

of the pack would take the organs first, because they were so depleted from the hunt.

And there's just full of nutrients, they're full of growth factors, growth factors, peptides, nutrients, one of the most nutrient-dense foods on the planet, and I'm like, you, I don't love, like, I don't love eating texture. Yeah. The texture, there's taste stuff, and we've got interesting things these days to eat,

like highly processed, salty, and sweet at the same time, we were like, the food scientists know what they're doing, right? Yes. I've checked our physiology, essentially. Look at nerd's gummy clusters and the revolution of that company just by making it look

like a COVID-19 particle, actually. Yeah. Exactly. Delicious.

There's just so much in those organs, it's incredible.

And there's a lot of interesting science, too, now I'm not the science guy at the company, but there's a lot of really compelling and interesting research about what is in, like, let's say a gut lining tissue, there's peptides and stuff that can actually help your gut lining. There's a theory called, like, light supports like, and I think it's really fascinating and

interesting that folks that have, like, thyroid, hypo or hyperthyroid issues can take thyroid in it, it can help with those types of things.

“I've gone down that rabbit hole as well, and I think that's why I was trying to relate a”

little bit to the, the, are what you eat thing, but let's leave it there, but you brought it up, and I have to ask, what was this three-month, uh, free-deen program, like, was Paul already kind of, uh, breaking out in terms of, of his popularity or, yeah, walk me through that decision.

Yeah, um, he, he was breaking out at some level.

This is pretty, and this is before he was on the, on the Joe Rogan podcast, he had wrote, written a book, uh, called The Carnivore Code. I, uh, you know, it was very plugged in. I listened to every, health podcast, read every book, and I knew who he was. Actually, a funny story is, I, I found him on Instagram because I, I tried a carnivore diet

for a while, and when you do something that feels really out there in relation to, like, mainstream, whatever one does, you know, when you, when you decide, like, oh, I'm only going to eat meat and nothing else, that's a weird thing, right? And it's especially unsettling when you don't understand, at least for me, when you don't understand, maybe the, the foundational science underneath it, right?

“'Cause you're like, you feel like you're taking this gamble, and you're like, am I right?”

Am I wrong? Like what? Yeah. Like it worked for Jordan Peterson. Yeah.

That's not enough to go on necessarily with your long-term. Exactly. So that wasn't enough for me to do it long-term. I was, I, I tried it, and I felt a little bit like uneasy about it, and so I started searching for answers, and I found some, you know, some interesting forums, a guy named Sean Baker,

who's a, he was an ex-surgent, you know, talking about it in a more medical way. Anyways, I stumbled upon Paul, who, you know, at the time, I think, man, he was in San Diego. He only had a few thousand followers, he's talking about the diet. So I followed him really early on, and funny story, I sent his profile to my brother-in-law at the time.

This might have been 2018 or so, and I was like, "Hey, watch out for this guy. He's going to be on Joe Rogan someday, 'cause I really think he had this ability to explain the science in a way that made sense to where it was like accessible. And nobody else was talking about it. So I right off the bat started consuming his content because it helped me feel more confident

in the choices that I was making. And I think that was part of, part of his appeal with, you know, we had the time of COVID. We had kind of this carnival, dire thing going on, and it kind of all met at the same point in time around 2020, which caught a lot of steam. And that's when I had met him.

Anyways, I worked for free because, I mean, you know, you meet somebody who's starting to company on the street. They don't know who you are. They don't know what you're capable of. And I was just very much into liver supplements, as weird as that sounds.

They had benefited my health, and I was, I wasn't bored in my career. I was doing quite well. I was a fint-out company, you know, I wasn't looking for work necessarily. But I was just into what the whole story of this company and what we were doing.

I worked for free.

I popped over there on the day a launch and packed supplements, swept the floors, and little by little, you know, I was solving bigger problems and bigger problems and bigger

“problems and about three months in, it kind of got to the point where I think they were”

like, well, we can't imagine doing this without Dean. And so I came on full time. That's a beautiful, uh, really cool story. And I know a lot of your growth, or I think a lot of your growth in the initial days came from the organic growth.

It came from organic side of things. How quickly were you guys integrating paid, like our aggressive paid into into your growth strategies? You'll notice if you talked to me for a while, I'm very, I forget numbers and I, I get the bigger picture, but I, I don't remember exactly when that was, what I do know is, we shot

of a cannon, um, organically, we didn't have one paid ad for probably, if I had to guess it was two years. And our growth was, I think, don't quote me on this, but I think three years and we

were close to 50 million in top lines, organic, all organic.

Yeah, primarily we were mostly, yeah, we didn't run an ad for a long time. And, you know, I've talked to a lot of people and been on some podcasts for people were like, okay, what's the, you know, how do you do that? What, like, how did you guys do what you're doing?

“And the one thing I say is like, well, I'm not responsible for that, right?”

Like, I get a lot of props as being the CEO of this company, but, um, the truth of the matter is, is we had a founder who put in, like, four years of sweat equity, building an audience. And not even really with the intention of building an audience, but there was a problem in the world and something that he was into helped, he wanted to solve it, and he added

value to people's lives. And so he did that for free for four years, and that really was the springboard along with some timing of COVID and some other things that really propelled, um, you know, the whole way, the whole organic way. My part in it was, okay, we've got this opportunity, right, to collect demand, to convert

demand and to retain customers and to build a world of mouth and to do the absolute best that we can for our customers, you know, let's not sacrifice and cut corners on product. Let's put a person behind the keyboard to talk and answer every single question from every single customer that comes in and we were getting thousands and thousands of emails from people.

We built really like the CX arm first, the surprise and delight aspects first, um, and a lot

of our effort went into supply chain and product quality and simplicity. We decided to stick with the D to C first and not expand into many channels. We actually made a mistake in the beginning where we were trying to do too much. But yeah, it was all about the customer, it was all about the product and it was all about just serving them to the best of our ability.

What was that mistake? Oh, we, the mistake was really trying to shiny objects syndrome, right, like you're your new to market, people are buying your stuff and you're like, oh man, let's sell this in Australia, let's sell it in Africa, let's sell it here there. So we were in like, we were selling all over the world, all kinds of issues came up with

that. We screwed up our subscription program in the very beginning. We didn't really think through it and we didn't have an infrastructure at the time to to keep things in stock. So we had all kinds of, these are like issues that aren't as big of a deal today because

you've got better systems and platforms. But at the time, you know, we didn't even have like a gorgeous set up or CRM. So we're like, and we're in a Gmail inbox, you know, trying to tell 3,000 people that their order's not coming. Yeah, oh my god, and you'd be getting traffic from everywhere.

So that signal would be like, oh, well, let's sell to all the places that we're getting traffic from, but that could lead you into challenges, as you're saying. Everywhere. We were on Amazon. We just had a tough time.

It was, it was tough on the supply chain side, you know, we're dealing with cows. We got to put orders in like a year, year and a half, sometimes before we actually make the product. So it was really difficult with that organic demand to actually estimate what are we going to need, how much, and that caught us in some rough spots here and there.

Like a lot of CEOs and leaders in this space, you're also, like I, you're in the, the D to see snappers group. They're chatting a lot about, you know, social, we paid social growth and how people are architecting across different platforms and channels.

I'm always amazed when CEOs are as involved in those conversations because they are

“the shiniest objects in our ecosystem, I think are all these amazing tools we have for”

growth. So fast forward, your first two years were all organic.

Tell me about the journey into, into paid where I assume right now you're, yo...

balanced portfolio of organic to paid at this point. Yeah, much more balanced, probably more on the, on the paid side now in terms of acquisition volume. You know, some of that's environment, your environment changes. It's very difficult to, I guess it's different for every brand, but for us, once we hit

kind of that 40, 50 million top line mark, the, the organic, not volume, but just like

how hard it hit kind of started to dissipate.

“And so yeah, a couple of things that we did really well, I think what we did really well”

is we tried to build the right systems on the paid side in the beginning. We did a decent job collecting, converting that demand through really bottom of funnel, you know, ads. The top of funnel was being driven by our founder, by some of the things we were doing. We produced a couple of theorems that, you know, helped on the top of funnel.

So we did that well, but we really weren't forced to build much of a muscle in acquisition. And I love, I'm taking this off to a little bit of a rabbit hole, but, you know, I love sports analogies. It's kind of like, I don't know, if you have a football team and you've got a really great running attack and you can win games just because you're so good at running the

ball, but you know, you don't know how to throw the ball. And then pretty soon, the team start catching up and they start configuring their teams to stop your running attack. And then pretty soon, you got to pass the ball and you're going into games like, well, soon, we could kind of pass the ball and we had a good running game, but now that the

running games not good, like we might need different players, we might need different schemes. We might need a different quarterback, right? We kind of got into this place where because of the selection pressure of your environment, we weren't really forced to build that muscle early on. And so if I had to do it again, going back to 2022, I would have applied more pressure to our

team and probably do certain things internally to force just a stronger muscle in the paid side because we really kind of stumbled our way. Once the tide started shifting a little bit, you know, our funnels were really fragmented. They still are in a lot of ways. Our creative, we're just throwing a bunch of stuff at the wall, not really starting with

maybe the persona. We're just like starting with features and benefits and just throwing a bunch of stuff out there and not doing a very good job with kind of the top mid funnel and then converting that. It just wasn't working very well with us.

So we've hit a number of roadblocks since then, really in the last year, trying to build those muscles back.

“And are you doing that mainly internally, are you working with agencies or both, I guess?”

Yeah, a little of both. One agency that's been super helpful, we work with CTC for a long time, man, they've helped us so much and they've helped us a lot, really tying our kind of financial plans in the marketing, which is, I guess, a different type of conversation. Yeah, they've helped greatly there and we got, you know, in a few sticking points last year

where they really helped us unlock some volume. And then internally we've had, man, we've tried all kinds of different things with pod-based content creation, fly-reel and that's evolved a lot and now we're kind of, we're simplifying things again. We're going back to like, okay, and this is actually the funny thing coming from a content

background is, I don't even know if I can put into this, this into words so much. But one thing I found interesting with, like, D to C when I came in because I was a complete outsider, especially to pay ads.

I produce some fun for bad ads but I never was in the weeds of it and what gets me

is like the conversation for a while was just volume volume volume volume volume volume volume. And I get that to some extent but I've always been a quality guy and not in the, not in terms of like polish but quality of messages like my, my thing when I was a filmmaker is like who are you talking to, what tools do you have at your disposal, and tools when I'm seeing tools, it's like what's the graphic, what's the message, what's the sequence of your video,

what's the pacing, what are the cuts, the camera angles, like all these are communication tools to convey a message to an audience.

“So you have to understand that audience, you have to understand what you're trying, where”

you want them to go, right, what you want them to do, you want them to take this action or feel this way, and that's the quality to me, that's a quality of the message.

And so I always like would kind of scratch my head with the volume thing because I feel

like the quality conversation would either get misinterpreted to like quality of product

Technical quality, but the creative messaging quality oftentimes got lost and...

on like the messaging quality, which I love.

But I feel like it's been that this entire, the entire time. It has, the more things change, the more things say the same, and it's just forcing marketers to get good at, the word that came up, that through our strategy team at pilot house,

“that we use a lot, that was a word that Don Draper used all the time, I think, was salience,”

which is such a good word, and salience is like the combination of your avatar, but it's also like your product and your product's role in their life and the moment that they're in as it relates to your product kind of thing, and it's like it's like that one layer deeper even than avatar, and it's just like so important to, in my view, to telling the stories and for unlocking the messaging that matters in the, you know, and drama, I guess

it's not in drama anymore. It's more gem, in terms of like getting selected as the right ad in that moment for that user. I love that. I have you ever gone on the rabbit old like, how the algorithm, I know some people get

frustrated with it, but I actually think it's getting closer to like truth, right? It's, it's, it's like, it's recognizing who the person is, what they look like, what there's, like, it's just wild to me that the advertising world oftentimes is like seen as this like synthetic fake type of thing, but it's actually getting very, very good at letting the cream rise to the top and getting the right message to the right person, not

through, like, gaming it, but through, like, actual, actual, like, authentic communication. Yeah. I don't know if I described it the right way, but you did. You did really well. It just rare we get such a non-cynical, optimistic on what advertising is in the world.

I appreciate it. I love, again, I just love it that you've got all these CEOs of these eight figure and beyond companies that are, that think about like what the algorithm, that are thinking about,

you know, the technical side, because it's been such a powerful growth engine for, for

every one of these companies. Yeah. I love it because, again, if I zoom out, I'm a storyteller at heart and where our products meet the storytelling is like, I know there's millions of people that are suffering with chronic autoimmune conditions, or they just don't feel right in their body, or they

have this identity and version of themselves that they want to become, but they've had friction in that, and I love that the algorithm can get our content to those people, so we can help.

“That's why I think about it, and I don't have to hack it, like, I hate shortcuts.”

And back in the day, it was just like, you said to like, try all these tactical things that just felt kind of sort of leveled to me, and now I'm like, no, I can have a real person, that's why this UGC thing tribe is blowing up, because you've got, you've got a real person, talking about it, and that piece of creative is going to go to a person like them, and I just, I love it, you know?

Yes, that was my next topic of discussion is sort of the more people, I hate giving free advertising on the podcast, but the more entrepreneurs I talk to, we just did a big dinner in Vancouver, we had almost 50 people out, which was crazy, and a bunch of people were talking about tribe, and a bunch of people were talking about how it's sort of taken over as like a huge chunk, this guy was saying 90% of his ad campaign, what's your experience

with the platform? Yeah, so I'm not in the weeds in it, but I do know we've got about, man, I think we're deploying anywhere around 100 to 200 videos, like almost a week through that whole thing.

“And so, it's funny, it is volume, it's still his volume, it's both, right?”

It's both, and I guess I didn't say that earlier, but the thing has always been to me,

is it's both, and we've never been in a world like we are today, where you can actually achieve both, and you can do it fast. I used to, when I was actually in school learning about content production and guiding clients, it was like you'd see this triangle, you've probably seen this before, and it's like quality, speed, cost, and it's like the hard rule was you could only pick two, you can't pick

all three, you know, you could have quality fast, but it's going to be expensive, you could have it cheap, and you could have volume, but it's not going to be good, right? Quality's going to be low. And now that triangle, you can get all three, and tribe is an example of that. I mean, in the past before, like having these platforms, how difficult was it to create something

where you could output real people's story with video at that type of scale, you couldn't do it. And truly be on the same skis with those people so that the market itself is optimizing for the ones that drive sales.

100%.

Yes. Yes.

Yeah, it's been a big on lock for us.

We were just a little storytelling, we were producing a lot of video content, our accounts like 90% video content, and that might actually be a mistake. I don't know, but that's just the way it is. And we were producing a ton of stuff internally, and it was working for a while.

“Like we, our entire team will get in front of the camera, right?”

Like we all use the products, we all live the lifestyle. So we've got a headquarters here, everybody's in person, and oftentimes you'll see people out shooting Instagram reels. And so we were producing a ton of content, and it's quality content, in terms of we were saying the right things, but I think what was going on is the algorithm was like, oh, these

are the same people talking really about the same thing in the same environment.

And you know, they're not sending a 20-year-old female talking about her package. They're not putting that in front of the mom who's 50 and struggling with whatever she's struggling with, right, whereas now utilizing tribe, you have a 50-year-old woman talking about her struggles, and that ad is going straight to that person. So we, uh, hit a bit of an efficiency wall with the internal content that we were creating,

and we completely scrapped it more or less. We were so producing a little bit, but we scrapped like almost all of it, and we transitioned to, to tribe in some, our internal creator network that we have. How do you feel about it on your P&L?

“I think that's one question, I think I was, we were in that, in that sniper's group, we were”

talking with someone who's doing it, and he was just like, with the biggest, the biggest companies in the world, the enterprise clients, like it's too big of a line item, to be giving away, to be paying GMV for those kinds of companies. How do you feel about how it shows up on your P&L? To be honest with you, I don't love it right now.

And I'm thinking more, some of the creator stuff on TikTok shop, I haven't quite figured that out where I'm happy with what it looks like on the P&L, and I keep kind of waiting for the bigger efficiency gains at scale, and it's not quite there yet. So I think the jury's still out on that, but I'm a pretty big proponent of testing, and I'm like, hey, sometimes you've got to go all in, and you've got to switch things up and

see how things move, and might adjust it, but we're kind of in that phase right now, where it has helped us quite a bit, but yeah, jury's still out.

“We have all in, I think the last time we're trying to get this podcast together, we were”

talking about talking about some of the things that you've built internally with AI, and I think you've got some things that go right into your personal, I'd be just interested to hear a little bit of an overview about what's working for you, with how you're using these frontier LLMs. Now, it's crazy.

I gave a keynote at the Commerce Roundtable on April about this system that I had built. And when I got called to go do that speech, I was like in January, and I was building this

thing and it was incredible, and then by the time April came around right to do my keynote,

I was like, I'm doing this keynote, but none of this is novel anymore. So that was kind of a weird thing that the pace of technology is moving so quickly, that the thing that I was doing in January, which everybody that I talked to about, it was like, oh my gosh, my mind's blowing about how are you using this, they when I talk about it, it's like, duh, is the, you know, this is the same stuff I'm doing with it.

But essentially what I had done is going to sound so outdated in January, we were hitting some walls with performance, a lot of it on acquisition, and I just, I like taking personal accountability, right? Like, if there's ever problem, I'm like, I probably should start with me. And it's easy, it's really easy for me as a CEO to be like, what is this team doing, what

is this team doing, why aren't we getting results here, what is this person doing? And maybe that is the case, but I just had this feeling that there's something I'm missing here that's not like, a tactic in the account, right? If feels like we're doing everything that all of these experts and agencies are telling us to do, like, I see it moving, but something else is getting in the way of our progress.

So I fed an AI model essentially, all of my contacts over the last, like, I think year or two, every meeting we had recorded, every, and this is organizational data, right? All the meeting transcripts, because we recorded our meetings across the whole company, all of them that I'm in, my emails are project management system, a sauna, slack, all of my communications, and I essentially wanted to use it as a mirror, back to me.

And I'm like, okay, what patterns are you recognizing in this data, organizationally?

Because I'm responsible for the organization, right?

I'm responsible for the cadence, the flow, the priorities, what we're working on, what we're not. I essentially had to go through the whole data set, and if AI is good at anything, it's good a lot of things, it's very, very, very good at synthesizing information across multiple domains, which humans, we are very terrible at that, and it takes a very, very

long time.

“So the minute, I think it was Opus, the minute Opus came out, I fed it all at data, and it came”

back with some surprising findings, and some of them, I was kind of aware of, but a little bit unaware of how impactful it actually was. One of the patterns that found was whenever, and this is more of maybe, this is relevant prior to people listening that have teams, or layers of teams, and maybe you're a marketing lead, maybe you're CEO, maybe you're a CMO, maybe you're a brand director, what I noticed

in the data that I didn't recognize before is that when problems would surface, would come out like big problems, right, like what's a good example. Let's say, and everyone's experienced this, our acquisition, our, our, our cacas and

as low as we want it to, to be, we keep, we've tried a million things, and we're missing

our targets. What would often happen is me, a CEO, I'm going down, I say down, not really down, but I'm

“going to the team level, and I'm like, all right, what's going on here?”

Let me help on the practice, because I take pride in being a collaborative CEO, right? I will jump in the trenches with you, I will look at the data with you. We will figure it out because I'm that kind of leader. What I realized is, is that every time I did that, which was over and over and over again, you know, subscription problems, CX problems, supply chain problems, we come up with a plan

and most of the time the plan was my plan, right, is when you jump in and you don't realize like, oh, you're the CEO, so there's, there's little things that are going to happen where people are probably going to be like, okay, that's a good idea, even if maybe they think it might not be, it ends up being your plan. So when the plan is successful and works, you've solved the problem, and when it doesn't

work, well, it's your plan that failed, which reduces the amount of accountability and agency that somebody has with actually solving it, and I didn't, I thought I was being this, you know, great collaborative CEO, but what I was really doing as I was training the team to bring me their problems, because they know that I'm going to jump in and solve it, and then there's going to be like less accountability there, and so that's

something I learned, AI instantaneously was like boom, after it analyze it, it's like you're

doing this, this is the outcome, try this, that was amazing, and there was a number of

different patterns that it found organizationally, and so to kind of wrap it up, what I try to do now is I've tried to build essentially an organizational context layer and a scorecard system for myself as a CEO and for the organization where it's taking the data from meetings, it's taking my interactions, and it's scoring based on a number of factors, like I have the say-do ratio, like if somebody says something, if I say something, if we say something

and meeting, how often does that get closed, right? And there's a percentage, it's like, if we say 10 things, we want eight of those to get done, right? If it's any lower than that, we've got a big problem, and we're going to address it right away. Anyways, I don't

“know if that answers your questions. And it hits home for me as an organization, I think”

accountability, as an entrepreneur who likes to start things, and loves the idea, and loves getting things going, and it is that accountability layer that becomes a challenge, and we're going through it actually right now with different layers of accountability and how it all, it kind of all flowed up to me and my co-founder for a really long time, but and then we would jump in and solve the problems, but then it like that do say ratio was off, and we've recently

gone through a repositioning where we've sort of elevated one of our team members to sort of be a bit more of the context, all like have more of the context, so it's not all just flowing up to us, and so far, the dividends have been good. We've recognized that on our own without AI,

telling us, it's always amazing when the things that AI can tell you about yourself, but you know,

that it's surprising to be like, oh yeah, I guess you do know that about me, that's good to know. I think one of the best use cases is just pointing it inward, because everyone probably has a mentor, maybe, and your mentor can't be with you 24/7, and it doesn't understand 100% of your context. You've got to go through a lot of effort to, you know, to get them there, and it's like, yeah, this thing pretty much can have all of your context, it's how you're talking in meetings,

It's are you following through your actions, it can really coach you in a rea...

open to it, and then also, I will say, I program this thing to be very harsh on me, because it's like,

I don't want, I don't want to guess, man, it's like, yeah, I mean, it will, it will gasulate you,

“unless you're telling not to do that's for sure. Well, and I think you've got to, you, you have to”

understand your philosophy and approach and how you want to approach business to, like, I don't think it's, if you just use it out of the box, it's, it's just going to pull the, the law of averages and apply it to you. So I have, I have this book here called The Enlightened CEO, beautiful book, this book has helped me in my position more, more than any book, and so the principles in this book on how a CEO operates, I've essentially distilled those into, into my model, and that's why I called it,

I called it Ellis, it was the Enlightened Leadership Insight System, and I pulled a lot of the

principles from that book. So that, that'd be another tip for people. It's like, you got to understand your principles and, and how you want to operate, and once you get that, it's pretty easy to put it into operation. That's a great, I'm going to, I'm going to get that summarized for me by my AI directly after this call. I was, we could talk all day about this. I, like, just in, in the last section here, what are you maybe most excited about or most trepidacious about about

Q4 this year? I guess with supplements, Q4, it can be a big time of year, but it's almost like Q5 and January is almost even bigger for you guys, because you're new year, new year, new you kind of situation. How are you thinking about the holidays this year? And what are you most excited about? I'm very excited, one, because we're watching a product on Cyber Monday. So something we haven't done before, and so I'm really excited to have a new offer on Cyber Monday.

That's really going to, it's going to hit hard with our existing customer base. So that I'm excited about. That is a whole-food electrolyte product, which we've been

“developing. I love it. What was that from, like, harvested sea salts kind of thing or something like that?”

Water, sea water, isn't it? We have bone in it for the, for the calcium and coconut water. And so I'm excited about that, because there's not a whole lot of electrolyte powders in the market that don't have like fake screeners in it or like fillers and additives and those kinds of things, artificial flavors. So we have an on-flavored one, just those ingredients that I told you, and then we have a coconut nectar one that's flavored, but it's with actual coconut nectar. And so I'm excited about it.

I'm an electrolyte nut, so if you need a review or some, I'm prompted UGC said me some. I'll send you so many ways, you're gonna address that after this, but we have Q4. I'm excited about that, so we have a different calendar this year, which I'm really excited about. I'm really excited to see how, I don't know, just the macro stuff going on right now. I'm not quite sure what that's going to look like across D2C compared to last year.

“I've read conflicting things on it. What's your cake on that? What have you looked into that?”

Well, you mean just like on the economy and people like, you know, spending behaviors kind of thing going into Christmas this season? Yeah, we did a podcast a few weeks ago that was about primed day on Amazon and the amount of people that were buying, not like the deal, like the big electronics, but we're like stocking up on their staples and stocking up on products that they already buy. So like customers being more wary and using those moments. And then in a way that

potentially reduces your contribution margin throughout the year because they would have bought that at regular price. And so I think you're gonna see a little bit of that. I think it's really hard to know. I know my stocks all took a jump after the election in the US with the idea that okay, things will be more stable or trouble be ramed in or something like that. But it feels, it just feels, it, well, for the past five years, it's felt like the calm before the storm a little bit.

And I feel like everyone's kind of holding on. But I remember, I remember I bought a house in like 2,000 in nine, like right after the last finest of crisis. And like nothing, like it felt, there was a crisis then and a lot of people, but like it didn't, you know, maybe being in tech, like it just felt like we just kept, I look back and I'm like, we just kept on trucking. And I, I like to think it's gonna be the same situation here. I'm no prognosticator, though. What do you think?

I, I share that view and I also think like since it is a more or less of discount holiday, I think we're gonna see a bump in general just because of that. Yeah, so I don't, I'm optimistic about it. And for us, I'm really optimistic about it just because, I mean, health, it sits on the

hierarchy of, of needs, you know, it's kind of at the base. So I always tell my team that. I'm like,

You know, if people are spending less, it for us, the health portion really m...

livelihood. And so it becomes a marketing problem. I'm like, we're not connecting in the right way

“with the consumer or we're not being clear about the value prop and how this can benefit their lives”

or whatever the case may be there. So I'm optimistic, man. And Q5, for us last year, Q5 moment,

I don't know if it was us. It was partly us, partly maybe the economy. I don't know. I always

like to look what are we doing, so I'll blame it all on us. We didn't, we didn't execute very well, Q5 of last year, so I'm, I'm excited for a redo. And the new product thing, any time you can enter that, that, that time with not just a same same discount kind of thing, but a new product,

“a new, you know, a new market. I think it's, I can see why you're excited about that. And we tested”

the waters with it last week. We did a little VIP launch with our first batch. And I think we'll

be sold out of that tomorrow morning. So good signal. Have you ever thought how ironic it is that you're partnered with a guy with the last name, Salad Dino when it's a pure, when he's like a, when he's a carnivore entirely? Is that? I've thought about it. It's a weird, weird coincidence, I guess. The universe rhymes. I, I think, well, I think about Trump. I think whether's a guy that's like, you know, doing all these things, changing the global financial system, changing the way nations

relate. And his last name is Trump. He's like, Trumping. And it's like, the, the universe is a mysterious

“place, Dean. We could change his name to stake Dino. Oh, okay. I'm down. I think that's what it is.”

Dean, thanks for coming on today. I'd love to keep it touch with you. Good luck this holiday season. And I'll see you in the sniper's group. Thanks for having me, Eric. I appreciate it.

Glad we could have met this work finally after two years. 100%. And go to heart and soil.co.

If you're feeling like you need more nutrients in your life. Appreciate appreciate it. Go there. And make sure you follow Dean on LinkedIn and Twitter for any pros and wisdom. But yeah, thanks again, man. This was awesome. Yeah, appreciate it. Thanks so much for listening to today's episode. If you're not a subscriber to our newsletter, you can do that right now at direct to consumeralloneword.co. I'm Eric Dick, and this has been

the D to C podcast. We'll see you next time.

Keep reading