The After Show: Death of a Showgirl

but we do also like to get into other kinds of stories, stories about policing,

or politics, country music, hockey, sex, of bugs, regardless of whether we're looking at science or not science, we bring a rigorous curiosity to get you the answers. And hopefully, make you see the world a new. Radio Lab adventures on the edge of what we think we know. Wherever you get your podcast. Hi there, everybody. So happy you're with us today. I'm Deborah Robertson.

“Welcome to 2020, The After Show. You may have heard the expression. I mean, who hasn't?”

What happens in Vegas? Stays in Vegas? Well, our most recent 2020 story actually did happen in Vegas, but certainly the awful details did not stay there. The episode that aired on Friday is called "Death of a Show Girl," and today we're going to explore some fresh details around this heartbreaking story of a talented, beautiful young woman named Debbie Flores Narvayez. She was only 31 years old when she died, and it's really a very heartbreaking story.

She was a bright woman. She had taken law classes after graduating from college. She was also a former NFL cheerleader ambassador, and she desperately wanted to be a professional dancer. She wanted to fulfill her dreams of becoming a star. Maybe even see her name in lights one day on the Vegas strip. On January 8, 2011, police found what is really so hard to even

“talk about. Her dismembered body and cement filled bins stashed away in a closet of a vacant home,”

just a few miles across town. And the big question, of course, was who could be capable of such an unspeakable crime? Was it some crazy stalker or maybe an obsessed fan? Police were looking at all of those ideas, and it took just about a month before they would zero in on her killer, and it turned out to be somebody she knew and loved. Well, today we're going to take you inside the reporting of this story. If you had a chance to see it on 2020, you know some of the details.

If you didn't, you will hear even more. Today from our investigation, even an exclusive prison interview with Debbie's killer. Debbie Flores is dead, and she did not deserve to die. I'm not trying to get out of responsibility. I'm not trying to diminish what this situation is

by any each. This was actually the first time that this man has ever spoken out publicly,

“and our chief investigative reporter Josh Margoan worked on this story. And he has actually”

here to bring us some exclusive details on the investigation, the prosecution of it all. Josh, welcome. I do. Let's start off talking about this woman. A woman of Puerto Rican descent from the East Coast, who had moved out very intentionally to Las Vegas, trying to make her name as a dancer. Yeah, we're talking about somebody who was intelligent, who had a lot going for a lot of energy. Her dream was to be not only a professional dancer, and like you said, see her name in lights,

but she wanted to be known for her choreography. She was thinking about down the road, maybe going into the business side of professional dance. And I don't know if that in her mind meant running a company or running a series of companies or running a theater, but she saw this idea of moving from the East Coast where she was from, Baltimore area, to moving out to Vegas as an opportunity for the startup and the celebrity. So she had already achieved some status as a dancer.

She was good. She was good. She was very, very talented. And so she goes out there and her goal was to, was to hit the strip and to be a professional show girl. She winds up, you know, as a feature dancer in one of the longest running, most popular high-end shows on Las Vegas strip, this is not an easy needle to thread. Yeah, well help us understand that because she did get her dream job working at the fantasy burlesque show at the Luxor Hotel in Casino. The Luxor is one of the

big fancy hotels that are very, very famous. Yeah, so tell us a little bit about that world. I've

been a Vegas once or twice on shoots. I mean, I never really have taken to going out there with

friends as many people do. Talk a little bit about that world and what that is like when people come out there with aspirations. First of all, it is a very demanding job being a professional dancer at a high-end show. And we are talking on the strip. We are talking high-end. This is not low rent. This is not some sort of a, you know, a second or third rate kind of a thing. There are women from all over who compete for these positions and they are prized positions and may hang onto them for

derelict. Because people are paying big bucks to come to the shows and they end in their heyday, you know, let's step back even further that Las Vegas show girl is an icon. On the strip, 30 years ago, Luxor, which at that time was one of the new age hotels, it was, it's built like the Egyptian government. And in those pictures, so it's down at the part of the strip where you have new

when it first opened up and it has this burlesque show that's very high-end and it has a small

“company of dancers. It runs, they advertise seven days a week, 365 days a year, every single”

day. So she becomes. But the dancers, that's demanding too. Very demanding. In fact, the dancers work five, six, you know, days a week and, you know, the show, the curtain is 10 30 at night. So that takes a toll also, you know, the Vegas lifestyle to just city that lives at night. And so you have that. So Debbie gets on first, she's a replacement dancer, a film dancer in this small company at fantasy. So fantasy is this show at the Luxor. So she ends up becoming a film

dancer, then she becomes a regular dancer and on the way to, you know, her terrible end, she winds up hitting it big. She's going to be a featured dancer, a soloist, and she's going to get to perform with a guy who was a well-known, you know, music star at the time, Cisco. Yeah. So she is basically on the eve of rehearsals for, for this great moment. It's December 13 and she doesn't show up for rehearsals last rehearsal. The last rehearsal. This is back in 2010 and everybody knows that she's

very dedicated. She sees this as her big moment and her roommate reports her missing. So you mentioned

“you had a very, very good description of Vegas and what it's all about. And I remember being there,”

covering sick, free to Roy back in the day and, you know, there is like this allure to Vegas. But when you think about it, Sin City, that's almost a character in our story in 2022 when you think about Vegas, how much did that complicate this investigation because they are looking for someone in a town where, as you said, maybe somebody just wanted to disappear? That's exactly it. And also, remember, it's a town of, of transients, not in a negative way, but there's almost nobody that's

from Vegas. You have a population of people that are coming for work. A lot of that work is in the hospitality and entertainment business. Those are both businesses that attract people from all over who come in alone, unattached. So you don't, you're not necessarily finding people that are coming in with full families of four or five, but you have a single woman who gets in a car and Baltimore drives cross country to follow her dream. Who does that woman know? So she winds up having

“a roommate. That roommate could well be the only other person in the world that knew who she was,”

what she was doing, what she was about because otherwise her family was back home. And when she was last seen, well, you mentioned her car. She drives that car across the country. So, as police start to look, eventually, they find her car, a maroon geoprism, licensed place are gone and her boots are in the car. The boots that I guess that she had last been seen in, but nothing else. So it's kind of a break or isn't a break. It's a major break because what this does is it confirms the

hunches that the detectives had. The detectives behind the scenes at the Las Vegas Metro Police Department. They were working a missing person's case, but they had a spiny sense that they were working a murder case. They just couldn't put their finger on it. They didn't have a crime scene.

They never crime victim. They didn't have any, but they they felt if for nothing else, the fact that

she was about to be a star. At this show, fulfilling her life's dream, they felt that that was the reason why she obviously had had something had happened to her. Maybe she had been killed. They, they were worried about it. They were worried. So the finding the car with no plates, that's immediately suspicious because anybody is driving their own car is not going to take off their own plates. That's, that's the sign of somebody trying to hide something. And why they're going to

leave their shoes? Why would they leave their shoes running? Right? And if she disappeared because she wanted to, let's just exercise her for a second. She had enough of Vegas. She was angry at this. She didn't like living there. She was going to run off a genio to LA. Secondly, for car, exactly were shoes, that's a logical. Yeah. They knew they knew from that moment that something was up. So they start questioning the folks in her orbit, including her ex-boyfriend. So I want to

talk more about him, Jason Blue, Griffith, her ex-boyfriend, who is a person that they wanted to talk to. So when we come back, we're going to talk about the details of that relationship and a shocking twist in turn, in this case, where police began to look in the direction that would take them to the killer. So stay with us. We'll be right back. Thanks to HomeServe for sponsoring this episode, owning a home is amazing, until it's not.

One minute, you're sipping coffee and listening to your favorite podcast, and the next, your ankle deep in water from a burst pipe. Repairs don't care about timing, and they definitely

don't care about your budget. And they won't always be covered by regular homeowners insurance.

Issues like plumbing failures, HVAC breakdowns, and electrical issues might leave you on your own. That's where HomeServe comes in. For over 20 years, HomeServe has been helping homeowners get repairs fast through their network of over 2,600 local contractors, saying goodbye to frantically searching for

goes wrong, call HomeServe's 24/7 hotline to start the repair process. With 4.5 million customers

“and an A+ rating with the better business bureau, HomeServe is the real deal. Help protect your”

home systems and your wallet with HomeServe against covered repairs. Plan started just $4.99 a month. Go to HomeServe.com to find the plan that's right for you. That's HomeServe.com. Not available everywhere. Most plans range between $4.99 to $11.99 a month, your first year, terms apply on covered repairs. This episode is sponsored by BetterHelp. Did you know that 88% of Americans reported feeling financial stress at the start of 2026? So if you're feeling worried

about money or your financial future, you're not alone. And those worries can turn into troubled sleep, feelings of failure, or even relationship conflict. But therapy can help, and one easy way to talk through your financial stress is with BetterHelp. BetterHelp is the world's largest online therapy platform with a network of over 30,000 therapists. They make it easy to

access therapy even if you've never tried it before. Across BetterHelp's 12 years in business,

they've served more than 6 million people worldwide. To get started, just fill out a short questionnaire about what you're looking for. BetterHelp will match you with a qualified licensed therapist who's trained to listen. There'll be a sympathetic ear whether you're looking to unpack your relationship with money, build healthier coping strategies, or just feel less alone. All BetterHelp therapists work according to a strict code of conduct. And they're trained to listen

to whatever's on your mind, no matter how big or small. When life feels overwhelming, therapy can help. Sign up and get 10% off at BetterHelp.com/2020 spelled out 2020. That's BetterHelp H-E-L-P dot com slash 2020. Welcome back to 2020 The After Show. I am sitting here with our ABC Chief Investigative Report of Josh Margol and who really helped bring the story to life here on 2020 and it was called The Death of a Show Girl. It's the unbelievable story of 31

year old Vegas dancer Debbie Flores Narvaya as who failed to show up for a critical rehearsal and a

big event at the Luxor Hotel in Casino. This was a missing person's investigation, but as you said, the police were starting to think this is maybe a homicide or something bad has happened here. Give us a sense of their early thoughts. You mentioned that they are looking at her inner circle. There's that boyfriend or ex boyfriend of her as Jason Blue Griffith. He was also a dancer. He had been a notable dancer with what struck. They so lay and everything. What are they making

of him when they first start to look into him? They don't have any reason to doubt his genuineness is story, what he's telling them. They don't look at him as a suspect. And he's telling them what? He's just telling them, you know, he's answering their questions. I was less sorry here and what was your relationship about it? They had some trouble. A tumultuous relationship of their relationship. But he was being honest enough, nothing set off alarm bells. They have

“this missing woman. She's a beautiful woman who dances in a sexy show. So what if you're a cop?”

What are you immediately going to think? Some man, a fan, a stalker, somebody who maybe became obsessed in some way. Exactly. What ends up happening in the story is nothing like what detectives originally thought. What they're going to expect to have. Yeah, exactly. Because the plot thickens once they start asking more questions. So they wind up talking to another woman. And this woman had an interesting story that actually changed everything in their minds.

Colleca Sorso tells a story to investigators that Jason wanted to store something in her place. And she wanted to know what it was before she said okay. And he said, you don't want to know what it is. And she wanted nothing to do with that. She wanted nothing to do with that. Yeah. So when she tells that to police, that kind of changes everything. Then there's another chilling conversation they have with Jason's roommate, Louis Colombo. And it's a chilling interview in a

way where he essentially tells police everything. Let's just take a listen. I can guarantee this. You tell us what happened. You're not getting arrested. That's my guarantee to you.

“We know you wish you could rewind it. You can't. Now you gotta go forward. You need to tell us”

what happened from the beginning all the way to the end. You know it's, did you kill them? They're talking to him. You need to tell us what happened. I saw him choke him. They're not argument. I'm not holding off of him. That's why I got him water. And I asked him if they were going to be alright. I tried to tell him no more audio and no more fighting him. Colombo says he leaves the house for about two hours. When he came home, he saw Debbie

laying on the floor on the plastic bag over her head and she was not moving and did not appear to be breathing. He offered her an event. Yeah. What she called she. Yeah, she.

with some concrete. Louis tells us that he can take us to where the body is. So I'm going to

“abandon the house. Now, the question is where's the house on the house? Take us to it.”

You don't have to go in. What can you take us to the house? We got to go. We got to get it. This was a major turning point. In the case, once they start talking to Colombo, it's like now they know, right? How much stock do they put in his, well, they put tremendous stock in in Louis's comments. The, it's entirely possible that the case would not have been cracked, but for Louis's cooperation in this case. And Louis's cooperation was controversial because the police, the police

knew that their relationship between Jason and Louis had gone back to childhood. So they get the sense that Louis knows a lot. And Louis at this point in the story was already showing signs of somebody who was under extreme emotional stress. So they, they then realized he knows way more and they then

make the critical decision to offer him a deal. Immunity. Immunity from prosecution entirely,

“but the deal was very, very precise. We will not arrest you. We will not charge you. You can go your”

merry way if you had nothing to do with the murder. And by this point, they know that a murder has happened. They, they believe a murder has happened. They believe that Jason, the former boyfriend had talked to Coluey, they believe that that Jason had killed Debbie and was looking for a place to store Debbie's body. And that Colombo was a part of that, too. They believe that Colombo was a part of it and would know about it. And they had a sense that Colombo had not done the killing,

but he would have been involved in the hiding and trying to help hide her remains. And so the grizzly details do come out about this. And we want to talk about that later. But you say he was he was paying the price essentially for what he knew and and dealing with the trauma of all of this. Well, we want to talk about the details of what happened. Jason Griffith is eventually

arrested on January 8, 2011. He faced charges of first degree murder. And I want to talk about

what exactly police learned happened. And also the courtroom, once he made it into a courtroom, we're going to talk about what happened there. And he did something nobody saw coming. He took the stand. It's there. Don't go anywhere. We'll be right back. 2020 is partnering with Vibes Open Year Wireless Headphones. That's Vy BZ. If you listen to a lot of true crime, you probably like to listen with a good pair of headphones. But it can be tricky to find

a pair that provides great sound quality that's not too overwhelming. Because when you're out with a podcast during a late night dog walk or pre-done run, you don't necessarily want noise cancellation

“that blocks out the sounds around you. That's why you'll want to get yourself a pair of Vibes,”

your perfect companion in audio. They're designed for maximum comfort with ultra lightweight earbuds that sit just outside the ear canal. And they offer crystal clear audio. So no matter what you're listening to, whether it's your favorite song or a sound rich true crime podcast, it'll come across loud, clear, and silky smooth. The battery lasts up to 10 hours per charge and they come in a range of sleek modern colors and styles. So what are you waiting for?

Order now and you'll be listening to better sound with better headphones before you know it. For a limited time, our listeners can get more than 60% off a pair of Vibes wireless headphones. Just go to abcsecretsavings.com/2020. Again, that's abcsecretsavings.com/2020. Hi there. Welcome back to 2020. The after show Josh Margolin, our abc chief investigative reporter was here with us with more details than we could get into in our recent

episode of 2020 called Death of a Show Girl. Josh, you've seen plenty. You know, you've covered a lot of these stories. You've spoken with cops a lot about things that have happened. As we've been talking, this is the story of a young dancer who was gruesomely murdered by it turns out her

ex boyfriend, Jason, blue, Griffith. Ultimately, these two had a disagreement and what a police

determined, I mean, it's just so hard to wrap your mind around that this is a guy who she loved, even though they were not on great terms, but that she could be dismembered and her body could just be betrayed at this way. How did police begin to unravel all of this? Police get to the point. First of all, it's a little bit in reverse. They find out from Louie who had cut a deal what had happened and they know that Jason and Debbie, the night that Debbie, they believe

ultimately, is killed that she had gone to Jason's home and that they were going to watch

people. And then, but they believe that they have an argument. Now, this is an argument in the

“sea of arguments in this relationship. Very volatile relationship. You know, she had vandalized this”

car. They had called 911, the police knew there was no evidence of any physical violence, but there was evidence of volatility in the relationship and it does seem that Debbie was very emotional and she could become very angry at Jason and Jason. He was open about the fact that he was a ladies man. He was playing the field and he was very, very clear with police that he was playing the field. And it seems that throughout the course of their relationship, the issue that really, you know,

was the overwhelming source of a problem between the two of them was the fact that she wanted a relationship. She had an exclusive relationship. She wanted to be together with Jason and Jason wanted a lot of women. And when he was asked, in a really telling moment in our reporting, when we talked to one of the homicide detectives on the case and asked Jason about, you know,

“why so many women, what's up with that, you know, tells about it and he said, it's Vegas baby,”

you know, Jason had also come to Vegas to be a professional dancer. He was an accomplished answer. He was good looking guy and he was well known, you know, among that set of people that professional performers on the strip, which is a really, it's kind of a verified space in that entertainment business. These are people who worked hard to get to where they were. They're in excellent physical condition, very athletic dance maneuvers. So he definitely was an accomplished

guy, but he, he wanted the sense city of Vegas. He wanted a different woman every night. He was telling the police that if he had a date and the date canceled, he'd call somebody else. He didn't want to be alone any night. He was a man who, who, who, who had this list of women in his life and he was proud of it and Debbie wouldn't have it. And so police are left with trying to figure out a motive. So they figure out that they must have had some big explosive argument. She gets killed.

He, he kills her and then he wants to get rid of the body. Right. And he freaks out. And that's where Louie comes in and, and Louie tells the police to story, you know, Louie had committed to them that he would take their deal. The no prosecution, no arrest deal. And the deal was that he did not have any part in the murder, but he would give them all of the information about what happened. But Louie did come back and see her on the floor. He did witness her lying on the floor.

After the fact that the point was, the cops drew a line of distinction. They know, in this case, they are not going to be able to make a case for murder, unless they have a witness explained.

“Remember they don't know where the body is. So they have to quickly make a calculation.”

Would we rather let a guy off, a guy who helped, you know, clean up the scene, get rid of the body, in order to get the killer or do we want to risk everyone going free. And that is a fairly typical quandary that law enforcement finds themselves in. And some people weren't crazy about the idea that Louie would get immunity. In their minds, there's a greater good here. The killer is going to face the music. And police determine he killed her how. He strangled her.

He strangled her. He strangled her and then had to get rid of the body. And remember, this is a very personal crime. It's the kind of thing that you, you know, strangling is an up close kind of a thing. Yeah, something very personal. So police make their case. Griffith goes to trial. He actually chooses

to testify. And of course, he disavows doing any harm to Debbie and says, basically, she

sort of attacked him. It was self-defense. Right. And the big question was, how is this playing with the jury? Because this is a guy who comes in, as you said, a good-looking guy who seems to be sharp and so forth. But the jury doesn't buy it. No. And it's a tough case to make. First of all, he added this, he had a testify because his defense is self-defense. So I felt that my life was in jeopardy. I did not plan to kill her, did not want to kill her, but she was going to harm me. Therefore,

I had to defend myself. Now, that's really when you have only two people down there. In order to make that defense work, you're going to have to testify on your own behalf. So the jury can hear your state of mind. And prosecutors and cops figured that Jason being a good-looking, charming, charismatic guy who had a remarkable way of making people like him. And he thought that would work in a court of law, but it didn't. Well, the jury doesn't buy it. And on May 22, 2014,

after 14 hours of deliberation, they actually find Griffith guilty of second degree

murder. And while prosecutors considered first degree murder, the jury went for a lesser charge.

but possibly from what Jason said. Second degree murder is a, it's not premeditated, right? So

“he's trying to say that this is something that was not planned. And it seems that the jury went”

along with the notion that it was not planned. Now, there's a lot of other questions, right? He didn't call the police and say, "Oh my God, I just did a terrible thing." And you know, helped me out of it. He tried to hide it. And then he acted with really heinous conduct toward the body of the woman at one point. He cared for. So obviously, the jury was not letting him out. But they were swayed by the notion that this was not a premeditated murder. Yeah, which was the best he could

hope for in that case. Well, you know, we heard from him in court, but for the first time, he actually

spoke out to our team from behind bars. And viewers would have heard some of that conversation on Friday's episode. What do you think about him in the way he came across? Do you feel that he took responsibility? What's you're thinking about Griffith? No, it does not seem that he's taken any more responsibility than he was willing to take in the courtroom. In his mind, it's more violent than any of the police information we got. The police characterized it as more of a harassment that Debbie

had had brought to the relationship when she was angry. Jason acts like it's it was more violent toward him that he was the victim of of Debbie. Yeah, he painted himself as a victim. Does he take responsibility for having killed her? Sure, he's done that. But he has an explanation and he has, he doesn't get why people are not accepting his actions. Is there a chance that he could? I mean, he got second degree murder. He could go free. The next time he comes up for parole, this is, you know,

“very possible. Yeah, yeah, that's what happens when you don't get the first degree murder charge.”

Well, let's talk about Debbie and her family because this was clearly a heartbreaking tragic story anyway, but just even so much more horrific for her family. Her sister's the last is in our story and she's still processing trying to come to terms with the loss of her sister, which is so painful for her, of course. But she's also too determined. She wants folks to see her face. She wants to be the face of the victim and her family. And she wants to make sure that Griffith

does not actually walk out of jail. And she wants to keep Debbie's memory alive. And she wants, look, the parole board is not obligated to give him parole. So in her mind, the way to basically effectuate the sentence that she wants to see him have, that she wants to see him, stay locked up indefinitely. She's doing everything she possibly can to less to see that come to fruition.

“Yeah, she really kind of broke our hearts in that story. How is she processing, do you think?”

I mean, obviously, she, her life will never be the same. Yeah, she's eager to tell the story.

She wants people to know what happened. She wants Debbie to not be forgotten. And she certainly isn't forgotten. What a story, Josh. Great having you here. Thanks, Debbie. And good seeing you. Josh has always welcomed back here any time. And by the way, I'll probably see you again because there's lots of other stories for us to talk about. So don't go too far because I think I'm going to want to talk to you soon

about another one. You can watch our latest 2020 episodes on Friday nights on ABC. And of course, you can stream episodes like this one anytime on Disney Plus and Ullo. Thanks so much for joining us, everybody have a good day. Hello, darlings, it's Lisa Van de Pump. My Hulu original reality series Van de Pump Villa is back in England, where the standards are high and the chaos unavoidable. And if you think my staff is

all drama, wait until you meet the guests. Love Island, virtual nation. The challenge. This is a white lotus of reality star. Witness the reality star crossover event you won't want to miss. New season of Van de Pump Villa is now streaming on Hulu and Ullo on Disney Plus. The 2021 6 NFL Draft April 23rd, 25th on ABC, ESPN and NFL Network also streaming on the ESPN app.