Limited Supply
Limited Supply

How to Turn Around a Legacy Brand (with Sandra Campos)

9h ago21:054,251 words

The Podafi briefing · AI analysis

PetMeds CEO Sandra Campos on modernizing a legacy pharmacy brand

4 min brief · 3 takeaways · Based on this episode’s transcript

The 30-second brief

TL;DR
  • 01Legacy brands can update digital experiences without full rebrands by prioritizing design consistency across all customer touchpoints.
  • 02Rising digital ad costs push legacy brands toward alternative top-of-funnel awareness tactics like radio and stadium sponsorships.
  • 03Direct customer listening through call centers and product Q&A sections reveals critical operational pain points faster than internal assumptions.

The big picture

PetMeds operated as a profitable catalog pharmacy before digital competitors emerged. CEO Sandra Campos now balances modernizing a 28-year-old public brand without alienating its 2 million active customers. She pairs incremental design updates with alternative acquisition channels to drive growth while fixing legacy technology issues.

Useful for: E-commerce operators managing legacy brands navigating digital transformation and customer retention.

Synthesis of podcast conversations. Speaker claims are not independently verified.

01Acquisition

Testing alternative acquisition channels

Campos notes that paid social and search are becoming expensive. PetMeds is testing alternative top-of-funnel channels like radio, stadium sponsorships, and brand partnerships to drive awareness without competing in crowded digital ad spaces.

Why it matters. Relying solely on expensive digital ads limits reach for legacy brands. Diversifying into offline or partnership channels can lower blended customer acquisition costs and reach new audiences.

Your next move · Podafi’s suggestion

Identify one non-digital or partnership channel relevant to your audience. Run a small pilot campaign to measure baseline awareness and initial conversion rates before scaling.

The catch. Offline channels often lack the granular attribution of digital ads. Do not expect immediate, easily trackable ROAS, and ensure the channel aligns with your brand identity.

Transcript evidence

From the transcript

“we're actually going to look at some alternative channels that are not competing in spaces that are becoming more and more expensive. Which is obviously Google and social”
Read the source transcript ↗

Evidence summary · paraphrased

Campos explains the shift away from expensive digital ads to test alternative top-of-funnel awareness channels like radio and partnerships.

02Conversion

Evolving design without full rebrands

PetMeds avoided a complete rebrand to prevent shocking its 2 million active customers. Instead, they focused on elevating website wireframes and ensuring design consistency across every touchpoint, from email to packaging.

Why it matters. A full rebrand risks alienating a loyal existing customer base. Incremental design updates improve conversion and trust while preserving the heritage and familiarity customers expect.

Your next move · Podafi’s suggestion

Audit your current customer journey for design inconsistencies. Update one high-traffic touchpoint, like your email templates or checkout flow, to match your core brand identity before overhauling the entire site.

The catch. Incremental changes can feel slow and may not immediately fix deep-seated brand perception issues. Ensure updates actually improve the user experience, not just change colors.

Transcript evidence

Evidence summary · paraphrased

Campos describes the strategy of avoiding a full shock to the system while still elevating the brand experience for their large existing customer base.

03Retention

Finding insights in customer calls

Campos personally listened to call center recordings and read product Q&A sections to find pain points. This direct feedback revealed critical delivery failures, prompting extreme operational fixes like personally driving to deliver medication.

Why it matters. Internal dashboards often miss the emotional context of customer friction. Direct exposure to support calls and product questions highlights exact moments where the brand fails to meet expectations.

Your next move · Podafi’s suggestion

Schedule time for your leadership team to listen to recent customer support calls or read product reviews. Identify one recurring operational friction point and assign a team to solve it.

The catch. Anecdotal call center stories can lead to over-indexing on loud minority issues. Validate these findings against broader support ticket data before making expensive operational changes.

Transcript evidence

Evidence summary · paraphrased

Campos emphasizes the value of direct customer feedback over internal assumptions, noting that leaders need to hear the actual pain points directly from the source.

From listening to doing

Take one idea into the week

Suggested experiments, not proven results. Choose what fits your brand.

Alternative channel awareness pilot

  1. 01Select one alternative awareness channel like local radio or a niche pet partnership.
  2. 02Run a pilot campaign with a fixed budget and a unique promo code.
  3. 03Track redemption rates and compare new customer acquisition volume against your standard paid social baseline.

Measure: New customer acquisition volume and cost per acquisition compared to the paid social control.

Guardrail: Stop the test if the cost per acquisition significantly exceeds your standard paid social baseline without corresponding brand lift. Do not generalize results from a single local market to national performance.

Context & limitations
  • PetMeds operates in a highly regulated pharmaceutical space with unique fulfillment constraints that do not apply to standard consumer goods.
  • The shift to alternative channels is a strategic response to rising digital ad costs, but lacks proven long-term attribution data in this specific context.

Listen to the conversation

0:000:00
Original episode description

How do you turn around a brand that’s nearly 30 years old, publicly traded, and has investors who are used to big profits and not a lot of patience? That’s what Nik gets into in this sit-down with Sandra Campos, CEO of PetMeds and former CEO of Diane von Furstenberg, recorded live at the Ecom Founders Q4 Summit. Sandra has done it all, from Polo Ralph Lauren and Juicy Couture to DVF, then a str...

Transcript

EN

Welcome back to Limited Supply, the podcast where we get deep into the tactic...

side of e-commerce, digital marketing, and building consumer brands.

“I'm your host Nick Sharma, I've spent the last nine years building, scaling, and investing”

in brands, and through this show in my weekly newsletter at nip.co/email, I'm here to share everything I've learned. The wins, the losses, the experiments, the tactics, and the insights, also you can unlock your next $100,000 in revenue. Today's episode is a good one, but before we dive in, let me tell you about our chosen

sponsor for this week's episode. Here's a problem with selling online, your customers expect a delivery experience they get from Amazon, regardless of how big your brand is. Store gives you the fulfillment network, software, AI, and robotics to compete while you keep the customer relationship and the data.

Over a thousand brands are to use it. Visit nip.co/store to see how it works, that's nik.co/st-o-rd. Welcome back to another episode of Limited Supply. I'm your host Nick Sharma, and today I have a really sick conversation with Sandra Campos. Now Sandra, if you haven't heard of her, she was the CEO of DVF, you know, the iconic fashion

brand, and then after that she led the turnaround of pet meds, which is a publicly traded pet pharmaceutical and pet, you know, medication supplements pet care company, and now she's working on a new brand, which I've gotten the front row seat to, which is also really exciting.

And in today's conversation, I've basically talked to Sandra about what it takes to turn

around, you know, a brand that has been around for such a long time. Also has a lot of weight at the top, right, because it's a publicly traded company. And you know, what are the things you do?

“How do you approach it and what is she going after from a priority standpoint?”

So listen to the conversation, let me know what you think. It's a quick one, and I think there's a few nuggets in there that you can apply to your own business. Let me know what you think. Should me a DM on Twitter if you've got any questions, and yeah, I hope you enjoy this episode.

All righty. Sandra, I'm so excited you're here. Oh, my gosh.

Well, first of all, I don't know what Jimmy was on, but let's take it down if you're

not just because it's not that great. I'm here, and I'm glad to be here next, thank you. We have gotten the chance to work together a little bit. And as soon as I looked you up on the internet, when you first, when we got in touch or in contact.

Yeah, I was talking to you, and then you finally responded to my email. Yeah, that. But I was so excited to work with you because of your history and everything that you've done. So, to start this off, first of all, I thought of this kind of as like a CNBC type special

during lunch, powerlitch, if anybody watched a CNBC. That Sandra, you went from the top of the top in fashion to be coming to CEO of a publicly traded company called Pet Meds. What is the transition been like going from being a board member and seeing the numbers on a quarterly basis and emailing back and forth to being the CEO and actually driving

those decisions?

Well, first of all, I think it starts way back because my career has taken a lot of different

terms.

“I think that's one of the most important things that I've learned over time is that the more”

skills you gain, the more well-rounded you are and more that you can actually, more easily you can make these decisions and understand what works what doesn't work and kind of how to catapult over some of the unnecessary decisions in business. So, just to kind of backtrack a bit, the pandemic changed everything for everyone, right? So I've had my experiences in corporate, Jimmy was mentioning some of those, those are

a long time ago, a lot of those businesses are a little different today than they were, but also had my experiences in entrepreneur, and that's probably if I were to say what was the most impactful business that I ever was a part of is actually being an entrepreneur because those of you who are, which is many of you here, that's the most impact that you're ever going to feel in your career.

You learn everything, I was customer service, I was PR, everything that you are and that you do. You're learning so much as an entrepreneur and that has truly helped me and that's been very pivotal in terms of even rising to a CEO role. So now four times in to your point when the pandemic was changing and I was at CODBF and

fashion known was buying $500 dresses when we were sitting at home in pajamas. So I then actually went to be an interim CEO of a supply chain company, 3PL, Jimmy, not very sexy, but at the time actually, everything was breaking down and supply chains. So that's when I got a lot of calls, a lot of information, a lot of learning and then started joining boards.

So I ended up having seven boards that I was on because I wasn't actively operating a business. I was doing the interim role, but then I was really focused on board work because I wanted to really take the skills that I had and learn about being on a public company board, learn about being with PE back to businesses and understanding both the differences between

BC back to PE back to public companies and what the different metrics are that they were looking for, what a success look like and each one of those areas. So I happen to have joined the board of pet meds because I have a lot of animals.

I have a lot of rescues.

I rescued eight horses, two dogs and a cat. So with all those animals, I'm quite obsessed with making sure that animals have their own home and that they're taken care of and have healthy, long lives. So I joined the board of pet meds a year and a half ago and over that course of the year, the board decided to make a change with the CEO and I became a CEO in May.

So there was a lot that I knew, but of course you don't know everything and to use to go into a company and start lifting all the covers and then start to realize who the customer is, what the opportunities are and really bring your team together to kind of take it to the next level. So the difference in terms of being on the board and being the CEO at operating it,

I definitely had a head start because I had a lot more of that exposure to what the company was and the core essence and the mission of the brand, but then also understanding more in detail now, of course that it helps accelerate the decision making and the accelerate what we can do in terms of transformation.

I love that you brought up the fact that entrepreneurship is such a powerful way to learn

and accelerate change and you know, as when when you were operating a private company now versus a public company, how are those levers changed in terms of how you can drive growth? Wow. Well, you don't have a lot of patience or investors don't have a lot of patience.

So obviously on a public company, you're really focused on quarter to quarter results. And there's a lot of metrics that after this company has been in business for 28 years and it's been a public company for 28 years. So they had a long run of being very, very profitable having $40 plus million dollars of the EBITDA and the investors were really used to high growth and really high profitability.

So now it's been about transforming the business to modern day, D to C because we are digital. It's 100% digital companies.

My first time not being in full on the channel, but really just digitally focused.

And so we have to take a different approach now. But in terms of the investors and how they look at it, at the end of the day, everything's about being, it's different today. Obviously, it was not only being private company, but it is about profitability and making sure that you're running the foundation of the business and just the key metrics and core

metrics of a company being profitable while also scaling and driving growth. So it's a little more complicated. It's a lot of pressure in many ways. And right now, as far as we're concerned, we are in a transformative state and really you're helping us as well.

I'm sure I'm so how we go forward in that regard. So 28 years, petments has been around in public. It is a massive brand.

“How do you think about driving brand awareness for a company that's already so massive?”

It's not as simple as just turning ads on or playing some of these levers, but you've got to take a company that's worth tens of millions of dollars and get it more eyeballs at scale. How do you think about that? It's definitely tricky.

So first of all, it is we're a multi brand retailer.

So over the course of the history of this business, it's been very focused on pharmacies. So most of our business pet meds as a name obviously is about medication. And so a lot of our customers know that and it was when it started 1,800 pet meds. The founders essentially took the business model 1,800 contacts and applied that into pet pharmacy and pharmaceuticals, and so that's kind of the origination of the business.

And with that, we've expanded over time into over the counter into food, we're accelerating food growth now, just to be able to be more well-rounded about giving your pets a healthy long life. But a lot of it is driving the pharmacy and the medication. So it's a needs-based business and in that needs-based business is prescription oriented,

“which is another obstacle because for prescription you have to have the veterinarian”

authorization and approvals process. So the core of our business and what I call the jewel of the crown in our business is our pharmacy and our customer call center. That's about 70% of our head count is in that and they are massively important to our business. So everything that we do is about the customer, everything that we do is about the communication

with from our company to the customer, but also from our company to the vet clinic as well. So there's a lot that goes on. It's quite involved. Obviously a lot of regulatory by state, where the only company that actually can ship certain products like GABA PENTIM, which is a controlled substance across the country

at all 50 states. So there's some things that we can do that we do really, really well. And now it's about saying, how do we take that what used to be brand awareness on 1-800 pet meds, which is Betty White for those of you guys who know Betty White? Who knows Betty White?

Please. Okay.

“She used to be in our commercials and so that's how the awareness really grew about pet meds.”

And it was 1-800 pet meds in Betty White and that kind of stopped happening maybe five six years ago. So since then, you know, this was the groundbreaking pioneer in online pet before chewy, before a lot of others that exist today. And they were really happy, just moving forward, growing business and being very, very

profitable. And then, of course, over time, like other legacy businesses, they didn't adapt and involve as much technology and play, didn't really structure where and hadn't anticipated where

The consumer was going.

So now we are focused on the consumer, where we are focused on how we create a much more

personalized, which most of you guys know anyway. But we're just catching up to be a more personalized, more focused on our experience online and then how we take that experience and flow it all through to when it gets delivered to your to your door. Speaking of experience, I think one of the things that I feel I've learned over the last

couple years is design impacts, trust, consumer trust so much like a well-designed brand will convert better and a poorly designed brand doesn't convert as well. I feel like you're one of the few CEOs who are such a great eye when it comes to design. How do you think about innovating design for brand that's been around for almost 30 years?

I call Dick Sharma. Really? That is.

“I think absolutely, it is, it's important first of all, it can come into the company and say”

we're going to completely rebrand and change the name because there's a heritage there. And there is and you know many of you guys who are out here listening today perhaps it may be cool retro to be 1800 although many of you may not remember having to use the phones

with the rotary but the reality is like we can't come in and just say we're going to

just rebrand everything because that's a shock to the system and we have a lot of very little customers. We shift more than 11 million customers over the time period. We have two million active customers that are actively on our site and that's something that we're accelerating and growing from.

So we can't dramatically stop and change but we do need to pivot and elevate the brand as well. So that's when literally I did call Nick Sharma and he's in the team have been helping us as it relates to our own website and just the wireframes and how we look at what the experience is and a lot of others as well they're bringing into the play but design is truly

important but the consistency I think is even more important, consistency of that design across the tone, the messaging, you know, everything they get that all of you know but just from the entire full all the touch points from email into the package.

“So all of that I think we're we're slowly moving and elevating it for sure but we didn't”

want to have a full shock to the system. Totally. Your customer orders from Amazon on Monday and your site on Tuesday they expect the same delivery experience. Store helps you meet that expectation with nearly a hundred full film locations plus software

AI and robotics. You keep your customer relationship and the data. They already work with over a thousand brands visit nick.co/store to see what they can do for yours. That's nik.co/st-o-rd.

So you mentioned some of the channels that help drive a lot of the awareness initially for pet meds. How are you thinking about driving sales revenue engagement for Q4 this year? So we're actually going to look at some alternative channels that are not competing in spaces that are becoming more and more expensive.

Which is obviously Google and social and I knew that's where a lot of people play but we're really going into some alternative channels where we look at radio. We're also doing a lot of partnerships and collaborations in some of which we're in the works right now but that will actually be awareness levels. We're looking at top of fun on how do we drive awareness now because we haven't done a lot

of that over the years we've been focusing and since I got into the company we've been focusing on retention. That's the first thing. We had to just say we're going to stop the lady and we've got to focus on retention. We need to make sure that our customer understands our value and get them a value proposition

from a loyalty play as well. So now we're starting to push out our acquisition strategies and how we do that, who we do it with across-wish channels and how do we really get to drive the most eyeballs possible? Whether that's through stadiums, it's boarding and the good thing is how many of you guys have pets out here?

I mean, it's literally 60-plus percent of the people that have pets, whether it's dog cat or other, it's an emotional connection.

So this is never a dual conversation.

I literally will talk to investors in the last 15 minutes I always reserve because it's showing your pictures of your pet. No one's unhappy when you're seeing a picture of your dog come on your screen, right? It's just my, oh, it's fun and no one's unhappy at our office when you walk around and you see all the pets in the office playing or just sitting in an office next to

their owner.

“So it's a really emotional connection and that's what makes it so joyful and so fun.”

So we know that this actually, I've never been able to say that what I do is live her death because buying a dress is not life her death. But here in this case, what we do is actually live her death for pets and really improving their health. It's also the part that we're trying to make sure that resonates from what we do internally

to externally to our customers, but they make sure that we care as much about their pets as they do. And so that's everything that we're trying to drive from within entire ecosystem. I love that you're so focused on the customer and making sure the customer understands exactly what petmets is and what the brand can do for them.

How, as soon as you took this role, how are, how did you go about learning ab...

customers and what they believe of the brand and then how are you using that information?

Well, first of all, I sat with customer call center and I sat and listened to them and

the phone calls. So I was listening to the customers, what they're calling, why they're calling, what they're saying, what their pain points are. I've personally been getting emails, responding to emails, getting, we've been driving medication where I can give a couple of examples for some customers that call.

We had a miss happen our technology early on and we were losing some orders. So one called and her pet her dog actually had cancer and she had been taking because it had been delayed and receiving the product. She'd been taking her medicine and splitting the medicine in half for her dog. And so she was on the last day.

I got somebody on the road. We drove up there, he drove and I said, you just going to get there before midnight. This was some time early afternoon and it took him eight hours to get there at 11.59 PM.

“She was able to get the medicine to the dog and that was really important because we”

started calling these things like Operation Jane Operation Dawn, whatever it was that we've had, where we've had some pain points, they've been lessons. They've been unfortunately difficult because we see the problems that we have, but they've also been lessons on how we can correct our future needs and what we need to do to be able to make sure that our customers getting the best services possible and the best experience

with us possible. So all of those have turned into how do we now create a new process, how do we make sure that what we're doing is communicating internally so that we can fully get the best benefit for our customer in the end. So that's one in terms of listening to the customer call center, too, is we have a Q&A

section on every PDP. There is there. So going in and looking at what are people asking? What are their pay points? What are they telling us?

You know, and again, this is a long time ago, but if you guys know express Victoria's secret limited, the founder of that in his office when I was very, very beginning of my career had gone to the office in the office, while said, the answer is in the stores.

And I've never forgotten that because it ultimately is the customers telling you whether

it's online and that customer is calling in and they're telling you what it is that their problems are what they need or they're writing it on a Q&A or they're telling you on social media, that's the customer and the answers are always there. I love that. The brand like PetMeds, I'm curious, you, you probably see so many ways that brands could

be doing better on marketplaces, right, even maybe when you shop, you see opportunities there. I'm curious from running the business of PetMeds, where do you think other brands could take better advantage of their listings and marketplaces or their interactions and how they work with marketplaces?

Well, I think it's tough, but at the end of the day, everything is, we have to get down to the minutiae into the end of the granular level of copy keywords. I mean, a lot of things that all of you will know, but we really have to scrub and I think that there's opportunity, everywhere to scrub, what's your competition doing? Where do you actually need to play?

What are the opportunities, whether it's images like every little bit of thing that we have to scrape these days because at the end of the day it matters, it matters in ranking, it matters in terms of customer perception, and so I think that there's an opportunity from a competitive standpoint, well, I know I was listening to some of the speakers earlier, and yeah, I mean, branding is important, but at the end of the day, like don't get bogged

down with it's not perfect. Go out there and drive some awareness and make sure that the customers know what you stand

“for, but I also think that you know, you have to be aware and cognizant of what the competition”

is doing. And I have to say just one thing because there's somebody in this audience that a long time ago asked me about the competition for one of the businesses that I was writing. And I say, oh, I don't care about the competition. I care about what we're doing at the end of the day, you really do have to care.

That's my goal.

I was like, when I'm wherever he is, but I've never thought I've never forgotten about that

either because it really is you do have to pay attention what's happening because the consumers have so many choices today. And you do need to be aware. We're also in a very promotional environment, it's very promotional for the balance of the year.

We know what's happening in our economy as well as obviously from a political landscape. So it's just making sure that you're really aware of everything that everyone else is doing or where you can continue to improve. I think that's the thing. It's just looking to make sure you're improving it all times.

Yeah. I always feel like everything can always be one percent better centered or more, yeah. To finish us off, you've been an entrepreneur, now you're a CEO.

“What's one piece of advice you'd give for everybody going into Q4 the rest of this year?”

Oh, Q4, I think try it all. If you've got ideas, I think one thing is let people on your teams have those voices and if you do, great, if you don't open it up because they're, I've been doing that now within the teams and the ideas we're getting, we're implementing and just going with it because you're going to fail and I'd rather fail and fail more often than at least try things and see what's going to work.

So just get out there and try it and be innovative and think innovation is key all of these businesses that are here represented today are innovative as are you and your teams into

A really cool amazing things.

So for the legacy businesses, like the one that I laid now on the ones that I've been

“a part of before, like that's what we're trying to do is really model after what you”

guys are also into.

So congrats for all the things you do and thanks for doing us for this amazing founder group.

Absolutely.

Thank you for being here, Sandra.

You're welcome. Thank you, guys.

“Thanks for listening, we'll be back next time to cut through the noise on CPG, retail”

and e-commerce. If you enjoyed this episode, why not share it with a friend and be sure to subscribe wherever

“you listen so you don't miss the next one.”

[BLANK_AUDIO]

Keep reading